|
i grew up on Mirage issues 1-11, it's still my favorite Turtles stuff, especially #11 and the Leo micro and awesome shorts like Don't Judge A Book and New York Ninja. there's a quality to TMNT that i feel like gets sanded off or forgotten about in many subsequent versions done by other people (the 1990 movie captures this too) which is its non-epic low-keyness. even when the Turtles are fighting Shredder or going to space or their lives are on the line, there's a down to earth quality to it that other adventure superhero-esque action type properties don't have, and i feel like most other versions are quick to rush into epic save-the-world superhero good vs. evil stuff. Shredder can't just be a ninja security firm guy, he has to be trying to conquer the world. the Turtles can't just be some turtle people who sit around and have adventures happen to them and then they go home, they have to be rushing out to stop bad guys and save the city or something. i don't know why people are so eager to make TMNT "epic" and plug it into the same generic badass superhero box, i guess because it's easier or because of marketing. i don't know.
i appreciate this stuff even more as an adult than i did as a kid, not that i didn't understand it as a kid, i don't think TMNT even at its most 'adult' is that complex or subtle (which is fine), i was reading Mirage when i was 10 years old and i did fine with it, but looking at it through the lens of adulthood, i appreciate that non-epic quality even more. i also appreciate the tone much more now, there's a great balance of light and heavy in those early comics, which is sometimes so skillful that you never miss a beat when the tone shifts and shifts back again. it's something that's kind of lost by the time Return to New York and City at War rolled around, and i love those stories too but the tone had become more flat and singular throughout the story rather than the juxtaposition that the series had up through issue #12 or so.
i'm not really sure where i was going with that but it's something i don't see a lot of people talking about, and i definitely think the Mirage TMNT is worthy of analysis and critique of its tone, themes, craft, but all i ever see is people talking about how the Turtles stab people and how "weird" it is that Shredder dies in issue #1.
that's another thing i like about the E&L TMNT, is that Shredder isn't some huge badass. even as a kid i thought he came off as a clumsy oaf in issue #1, and when he comes back in #10 he's still kind of dopey despite that awesome full page shot of him, he shows up in the decidedly non-epic setting of the antique store and then Casey beats him up and he's left standing there like an idiot, haha. then Worm Shredder in RtNY is kind of a dope, too, he goes down like a loser. i don't know if it was intentional or not or if he was meant to be cool, but as a kid i never thought he was cool and upon re-reading these comics i still believe that. i think that's part of the point. i think Shredder was meant to be dumb and it kind of annoys me how he's always seen as the ultimate badass or something. he's a loser! he's only in like 3 issues and there's a part in #1 where he falls on his head and another where Donatello hits him in the butt, haha. he can't even successfully throw a grenade. anyway, rant over. XD
|