|
I only ever saw a clip here and there during the original broadcast run, and man what a tantalizing teaser each scene proved to be. I had a vague but persistent sense that the 2003 animated series was a high-water mark for the franchise and for action animation in general.
I've more recently watched the first ten episodes or so and a few random episodes, including "Same As It Never Was".
...and the show doesn't quite work for me.
The best way I can explain it is this:
It is a show that's easy to admire, but difficult to enjoy.
Pros: It dares to take its premise and its characters seriously. It is stylish and mostly animated well. It is largely loyal to the original comics.
Cons: It takes itself too seriously, and for want of moments when the show invites the viewer to laugh with it, the viewer instead finds himself too-frequently laughing at it. For example, the turtle-themed slang that serves as substitutions for swearing; "What the shell?" and the like. If these goofy phrases were used for comedic effect they would be fine, but they are used for dramatic effect... and they are used over and over again. It's distractingly earnest and silly.
Ultimately, the series lacks personality. I think its most enthusiastic fans are those who grew up with it, who have the benefit of nostalgia, and those who place an inordinate amount of importance on the extent to which a given iteration of the franchise follows the Mirage comics template.
|