For me its a 3-way tie between Eastman, Bates, and Campbell.
Eastman is the orginal Mirage-era grit that got me into the turtles, and if his art was still crossbred with Laird's that would be my top choice.
Bates, as others have said, finds that perfect middle-ground between edgy and cartoony, and I think his art is truly the most well-suited to the IDWverse. I'd love to see him back on the ongoing after Santolouco and Smith (both awesome in their own right) end their run.
But I ultimately gave my vote to Campbell. Hers is the freshest take I've seen on the turtles since Zuli's hyperealism 20 years ago. They exude a true 'teenage' aspect, but can also flip the badass switch if need be.
Plus, Campbell geeked out with me about turtles for over 30min at con appearance a few years back, so that helped break the tie.
Really all of these artists are great though. Not a bad one in the bunch. IDW has been pretty blessed with talent, or rather, does a great job at finding it.