View Single Post
Old 06-26-2015, 10:40 PM   #6
Duke Nukem
Hench Mutant
 
Duke Nukem's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2014
Posts: 272
Quote:
Originally Posted by HotJuicyBurgers View Post
How is Splinter a better person? He raised 4 impressionable youngsters with the sole purpose being to murder another person. And yes, his master was defending another person, but was the murder really necessary? Surely a severe beating would have been enough no?
Sure, but it's a fine line between a severe beating and a fatal one, particularly when in a rage. Maybe a ninja master like Yoshi would be able to easily stop short of killing, but it would be hard for most people in the midst of such a fight to know when to stop. Besides, many of us have known people like Oroku Nagi, and they don't change for the better, and Tang Shen would have likely still been killed by Nagi if he had remained alive. I could easily see myself either losing my temper the way Yoshi did, or straight up committing premeditated murder under those circumstances.

Maybe Shredder's actions were justifiable as well, if he wasn't told about his brother's true nature and grew up believing that Yoshi had killed his brother in cold blood, and decided to show him firsthand what the pain of losing family is all about, before killing him.

I guess maybe Splinter isn't much better than Shredder as far as vengeance goes, but Yoshi definitely was. If you look at the bigger picture, though, Shredder ran a branch of a major criminal organization for personal gain while Splinter was raising his adopted family. I'm sure Splinter used his ninja skills to steal as well, but only because it was necessary to allow him and his family to survive, since he couldn't work and the necessities of life don't all float down the sewer. You shouldn't really make furniture out of turds, used condoms, and tampons.

I give him a pass for raising his turtle children the way he did as well. As a pet rat, Yoshi probably fit somewhere between a father and a god in his life, so losing him the way he did pretty much redefined his personality. Since Splinter had little contact with the outside world, he didn't have much perspective to change his viewpoint over the 13 years of training them to kill Shredder. Most parents try to indoctrinate their children with morals and ethics as they see them, from religious fanatics to police officers to regular working people, and Splinter was no different in this regard.
Duke Nukem is offline   Reply With Quote