View Single Post
Old 07-12-2015, 01:10 AM   #7
Duke Nukem
Hench Mutant
 
Duke Nukem's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2014
Posts: 272
You pretty much summed up what I think of Abanak, that he seemed a better fit for Archie than Mirage. Maybe it's because I'm not from New England and don't really get the whole hippie thing.

I also consider these issues to be Mirage canon, since there's no good reason for them not to be. I don't consider the fact that Laird and Veitch couldn't reach an agreement and the subsequent impossibility of legally reprinting these, to be a good enough reason to declare his work non-canon.

If any argument could be made for this being non-canon, it's that I feel like Veitch didn't quite capture the personalities of the turtles in his writing the same way E&L did, so they seem slightly like unfamiliar characters here. Nothing too drastic that I can't reconcile the story, but I guess it still seems a bit "off" at times.

I thought that Bloodsucker was too hastily written. One thing that bothered me about him was that he started off as an ordinary leech, but within days after mutating, he was fluent in English and knowledgeable about human customs and behavior to be able to convincingly impersonate a police officer (at least briefly). Splinter and the turtles took years to learn as much as he did. Maybe having 32 brains is an advantage. I do like the fact that he's a serious threat to the turtles, though, unlike many of the other villains the turtles encounter.

I liked the fact that Booder was killed, it didn't matter much that Bloodsucker was the one to do the deed. He deserved it for being willing to kill kids to run his factory. Anyone remember in 2008 when a Chinese factory was selling cheap baby formula with melamine (which tests as protein but causes kidney failure) and killed some babies and hospitalized thousands? I bet those factory owners didn't feel like their profits were worth it when they were being marched to get their brain stems shot out. Mannigan is not going to have a fun time in prison either as a former cop.

As for the old man, I don't know that we can judge someone over a million years old and that can rearrange matter by our moral standards. So it's hard to really call him evil, but he was certainly an enemy of the turtles though. In this case, Bloodsucker may have killed him, but he was a common leech at that point with no understand of killing or morality, and it was the old man himself that set off the whole chain of events, so there's definitely some poetic justice there.

Overall, I liked this trilogy, but I think it's some of the more overrated material in TMNT comics.

Edit: Also, if and when we get to Mark Martin's books, I'd suggest including #16 in with #22 and #23. Those three belong together as much as the river trilogy, and no sense getting rid of the best one of the three.
Duke Nukem is offline   Reply With Quote