|
I'm surprised for all this hate, or at least ambivalence, for Volume 1. It seems some people dislike it for not having an overarching narrative. That misses the point of the series. The guest era is like a parade of indie comics legends of the 1980s and early 1990s, plus great issues by the Mirage staffers. Let me break it down (I'm excluding all of the Eastman/Laird supermegacanon stuff, aka 1-12,14,15,19-21,48-62).
As for Mirage staffers, your boy Dooney gave us 13,27,48 and 49. He's not my favorite, but a lot of people love him. A.C. Farley gave us some great art on 29 and 43. Lawson did an exquisite job on 28. Berger gave his best effort ever on 45. Talbot delivered on 17. It's a crying shame that Farley and Talbot didn't draw more comics.
Regarding the guests, Zulli tore it up on 31,35 and 36. I know a lot of people don't like Martin, but his draftsmanship is excellent (and he really knocked it out of the park when they let him do the Sushi Turtles parody). Bode's pencils on 18 and 32 look awesome with the Eastman/Talbot inks. Rick Veitch is another legend, having created the excellent Maximortal and Brat Pack, and gave us 24-26 and 30. Richard Corben is immortal, and his art is sensational on 33. Matt Howarth is another underground king and created a fun story in 41. Admittedly, I didn't really get into some stuff, like Hedden/McWeeney, but there are a bunch of great goddamn comics in the "guest era."
You shouldn't feel like you have to read the issues in order, as storylines were broken up, numbers-wise. Also, for those of you reading these stories for the first time in IDW's awful, terrible, no-good colored versions: STOP. The fact that they redid the colors on Corben's issue demonstrates how clueless they are. In general, the power of Mirage Volume 1 lies in the toned, b+w art.
__________________
"All for one and one for all, up and at 'em Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles!" - Flaming Carrot Comics 25-27, guest-starring the TMNT, 1991
|