If we're going to go by what RES turtles look like in real life, we can clearly see a number of flaws in the design of the TMNT within the Mirage continuity:
- Why do they have teeth?
- Why do they have three thick fingers and two thick toes instead of five claws on each hand and foot?
- Why are their tails so thick?
- Why isn't their skin striped?
- And why don't they have red markings on their heads?
Pointing out the lack of accuracy to the RES species to argue against different skin colors doesn't really work when the general design isn't very accurate to begin with.