Quote:
Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
I think IDW is actually better objectively, simply because it has had a more consistent run and fewer "dud" issues.
Mirage has stronger stories (City at War, it'll never be beaten) but there's a ton of poor or mediocre issues in the Mirage/Image run that bring it down. Objectively, as much as I love both, I do have to maintain that IDW is better. Simply a matter of QC in my opinion.
That, and IDW April hasn't banged any roaches yet. 
|
IDW also has the benefit of being written by professionals who have 30 years of history to pull from. They're catering to a very specific demographic & have everything to please with at their fingertips already. You've gotta adjust handicap, here. IDW's not been without duds, either. Michelangelo's micro, April & Casey's series, Kevin's solo work, The X-Files crossover, others depending on your mileage/taste, it's far from perfect. & frankly we may have very different ideas on what a "dud" is. Some people find Mirage boring, but the slice of life quality so much of it has is what wins many of us over. We don't get to see as much of the new turtles' human side because it's written for trades & has to keep up the pace. Obviously it's a matter of opinion & we're both biased, but IDW has yet to really hit any of the deep/depressing/existential/introspective notes that Mirage did. Scraped the surface here & there, but there's a ways to go. It's mature only in that it has very detailed art, lots of action, & an older fan-base, otherwise it's very much Fred Wolf on steroids with bits of old & new mixed in, at least to me. & that's fine, it's what people come to expect (Leo's post about that nails it), but no other version to date can compare with Mirage at it's best (except for the first film but we all know where they got their material). It's just kind of a shame. You can forgive Nick for a lot because they're bound to Playmates' will, television censors, parents groups, etc. IDW doesn't have much of that, yet it still feels very neutered & toyetic a lot of the time. Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to be harsh. I own every issue + some collections, I commission the artists, I adore the thing. But if Mirage is Citizen Kane, IDW is... some other good ass movie from many years later that is less nuanced.

I don't have a good reference at the moment.