|
People don't make a fuss about Slash because he's been around for decades. He was introduced as a villain, one very different to the TMNT (design aside, though that too varied). He made a few appearances, didn't conflict with anything, had a cool toy, that's it. Then there was Mighty Mutanimals, they were smart enough to keep things separate. He made the ultimate sacrifice, which earned him even more props from fans. That is a character who earned their stay. He works in the now for the same reasons + nostalgia + he's unobtrusive.
Venus or any other turtle are fine so long as they're a sideline character (granted it's a bit crowded already IMO). When she was introduced in TNM, part of what made people hate her so much was that her involvement completely changed the dynamic of the group. There was sexual tension, a change to their origins, breaks in the flow to allow her screen-time, she was a mary-sue whose inclusion was solely the fault of focus groups who thought females couldn't relate to male characters (or maybe they just wanted more toy sales). Nobody wants a repeat of that. Yeah, you could "do her justice", but she'd be an entiiiiirely different character, what point is there to that? It's slapping a name on something new to create controversy or cash-in. Do I think Venus deserves a second chance? Yeah, maybe, but in a limited capacity, & certainly not as part of the fab four (or five). Even as a member of MM, it'd be forced. & can/would IDW avoid the inevitable? You're not gonna have a girl mutant turtle around without one of the boys taking interest romantically. You ignore it altogether, it feels unrealistic. You run with it, & everyone but the shippers cringes. What's the appeal? By all means, tell me.
The turtles are an iconic group of four, I don't care "how well" you do a fifth turtle (not you as in you, Sophie, you know I've given props for Artemesia before), it's just not right. It may have potential in an elseworlds tale, dream sequence, story of Michelangelo's, or fan-works, but it's otherwise just gonna rustle jimmies. The team is classic, you don't shake that up lest you're in the habit of jumping sharks.
& it's not as if the IDW series is hard up for strong female characters, they've very clearly been showing that chicks kick ass & contribute to the turtles' efforts (or pose a threat to them). Where are the complaints about that? I'm not seeing any.
|