I say leave the original #1 out of the poll and here's my top 3:
1. Dooney's take on the Mirage #4 you posted above.
2. Dooney's poster for the first issue of the TMNT Magazine from Summer 1990, which I think also had a seperate release as a TMNT movie poster:
http://thetechnodrome.com/images/alb...Tmag_90sum.jpg
3. The "Heroes in a Half Shell" VHS cover:
http://thetechnodrome.com/images/vhs/hiah.jpg
Honorable Mentions:
Archie TMNT #11
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Adventures #11 by
oldmanwinters, on Flickr
Berger's wrap-around (not pictured here) cover for Volume 1, #45. Maybe my favorite image of Leatherhead:
http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2009/...-vol-1-45.html
Dooney's box art for TMNTIII: The Manhattan Project. Really wish I could see the full layout of this someday.
But who knows, there are so many... my list might be different tomorrow.