Prices for TMNT #1 1st printing are all over the place and it's subjective to multiple factors. Pretty hard to nail down exact value / pricing. However, I'd put a CGC 9.0 at around $8k. An 8.5 would likely be around $7500 and an 8.0 around $7k.
Here are some recent sales to show you the wide disparity in prices for pretty much the exact same grade.
-
TMNT #1 CGC 8.5 $7800
-
TMNT #1 CGC 8.0 $9550
-
TMNT #1 CGC 8.0 $6500