|
I just broke the tie! It was 37 to 37 as of June, 14th, 2020. Now IDW is in the lead by a hair @ 38.
I am torn on this however. I want Mirage to be the best because of Issues 1-11, NORTHAMPTON Return to New York, Tales Vol. 1 (The Rat King issue is amazing), City At War, plus the wonderful micros... and then the brilliant moments of the guest era like The River. They're some of the best Turtle stories and some of the best comic books I have ever read. A lot of the guest era just plain blows chunks.
That said, IDW (more particularly the first 50 issues, along with background in the micros) gave me nearly everything I ever wanted in a turtle book. IDW's Shredder was exactly the Shredder I have always wanted. Post issue 50, Splinter's character arc and journey to bad-ass, relentless leader of The Foot Clan, flirting with his own inner darkness, was what kept me onboard. Seeing the TMNT grow and change throughout a nearly ten year continuity has been a blast. It's adult and mature enough to be worth my time yet has some of the kiddie-turtleisms that tickle my childhood too. Most importantly though, TMNT was cohesive. That said, a lot of the side-plots and introductions of new characters has made me exhausted.
So, each version is great. Each has its flaws. Neither are perfect. For me IDW edges out for the win. And I JUST BROKE THIS TIE, mofos!
|