Thread: New CGI movie
View Single Post
Old 07-20-2020, 01:11 AM   #271
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
Quote:
Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 View Post
IDW has just never figured out how to make the TMNT shine in their own book while also balancing a giant number of characters. Admittedly it's a damn near impossible feat. To balance that kind of writing... to write a decent story like that... takes a masterful skill that no comic book writer has ever had.
Kieth f*cking Giffen says "Howdy", brah. How'd you miss that one?
C'mon, man... it wasn't MY favorite run of "Justice League", but seriously... tell me a TMNT book written by Giffen wouldn't work better than Extenze. That'd be awesome.

But yeah, it's tough. A few guys could do it, though. That's the first one that came to mind.

Quote:
Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 View Post
I see Neatoman is being his usual self.
He's generally pretty f*ckin' neato.

Quote:
Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy View Post
Everyone here thinking Jennika will ever go back to being human isn't considering the base politics of the issue and public reception.

C'mon, guys. This is 2020. C'mon.
When you're right, you're right. Just like April's gonna be black in at least the next three movies/TV shows/misc. Same thing.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TigerClaw View Post
I'm no furry or anything. But I often find human characters boring to look at. Beings that look animalistic and so on look way more interesting and cooler to me then your average looking human.
See, here's my problem: I 100% don't believe you. I've paid attention to your posts on various topics for years and years and years. If you're NOT a furry then you do a great impression of one. And I'll lead in by saying, furries absolutely don't bother me at all. So don't think I'm insulting you, because I'm not. Not even a little. Just observing the evidence.

BUT, just like the message board "shippers" who ruin perfectly good TV shows and other entertainment by projecting what THEY want to see over what would actually be good for the story, furries have a habit of doing the same thing. "Oh, great, more things I can wank to! That's awesome, that's ALL I want and care about!" And those things are usually bad for the characters and story at large. Then perfectly good shows or comics or whatever else get "hijacked", because the shippers/furries make themselves so overwhelmingly vocal that the pen-holders have no choice but to cater to them, and everyone else just gets annoyed because they KNOW that what's being done is NOT what's best for the story or the characters at large.

I personally would have a LOT more respect for you as a poster and a person if you'd just say, "Okay, I'm a furry, I want more furry bait in everything, because it tickles me." That would at least be honest. I respect honesty even if I don't agree with the position a person takes, if they're sincere I can respect it. Instead, you repeatedly advocate for objectively bad ideas, and when people explain why they're terrible, you just keep bleating, "Well, it's what *I* want." We hear you. At some point it might be time to accept that Most TMNT Fans don't agree with you and stop trying to Square Peg/Round Hole everything.

If I'm wrong, then I'm wrong, and again, I mean no insult in my observation. Just saying, some of my best friends are furries and I thus can generally spot 'em. If you're not, then you do a fantastic impression. And I know why you might not want to advertise it, because people can be jerks. But what tickles you individually isn't what's best for the TMNT brand at large, and it would be nice if you at least accepted that even if you continued to be defensive about it.

If need be, I can recommend some books that would cater more directly to your personal tastes, although I'm not aware of any that are currently in-print. But they'd probably speak more to you than TMNT does, based on what you seem to like best. And we can let TMNT be TMNT without mucking it up with things that are only going to be bad for the brand over the long haul. The things you want to see are bad for TMNT, but they've been done elsewhere plenty of times. So if it's really about what you say it is, "I'd just rather look at animal-people than People-People", then there's ways to scratch that itch without sending a perfectly good brand down the toilet. Just saying.

The things you wanna see are bad for THIS brand, though, and saying "Well it's what *I* want!" over and over again doesn't make anyone want to agree with you. It just makes you look entitled. And that's no way to make friends.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
FW has been "borrowed from" more than enough, enough for a lifetime. For ten lifetimes.

Yes, a movie can borrow IDW's reincarnation angle as long as they promise that is the only thing they take from it.
I agree with you on Point 1.

Point 2 would get them banned in China, and possibly Japan as well. Can't do it, G.

Although frankly, devoting 20+ minutes of a sub-120 minute movie to explaining the whole reincarnation deal would be a lousy idea, anyway. It's not like in comics where they've got "unlimited" pages to tell the story. That'd be asking the audience to swallow a lot all at once, and we still have a lot more movie to get through. I don't know, I don't think it would work.

As I've said elsewhere, every TMNT version has its own One Thing that should never be carried over. Nick has Every Single Thing About April, 4Kids has Utrom Shredder, IDW has reincarnation. These ideas work well in their OWN TMNT universe but aren't good enough to be justified anywhere else. They're just not really good ideas, they're merely ideas that make their own version of TMNT "unique". And as others have pointed out in this thread, "Different" or "Unique" do not equate with "Good". In a vacuum, these ideas are all pretty cheesy and terrible, to put it bluntly.

Last edited by Leo656; 07-20-2020 at 01:20 AM.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote