View Single Post
Old 08-12-2020, 12:20 PM   #2
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy
Annalist
 
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 16,435
Yes, it had an edge. It's used shock value pretty effectively a few times (stuff with Slash, Shredder's death, Donnie getting cracked like a damn walnut). But the TMNT's own actions haven't ever really been a surprise or shocking; just the characters around them. And after a time, I think that grows pretty tiresome.

"Oh, sure, Slash gets to curbstomp an old man in a wheelchair. But none of the Turtles have ever killed even one enemy in over 200 issues? Whatever."

My problems with IDW TMNT are twofold: the Cast, and the Limits.

1) The Limits
It's all too easy to see the lines Nick executives have drawn around the IDW sandbox. These lines can't be crossed, and it's all too obvious now where they are.

The Turtles don't kill. There's not even an attempt to make it ambiguous.

Think back to 4Kids; Leonardo decapitated the Shredder. And yes, that moment was immediately neutered with what followed. But the intent was there; Leo was straight up willing to kill an enemy. And sometimes the fight scenes would be ambiguous. Raphael enters an elevator followed by Foot soldiers; when he walks out, they're all splayed on the ground. Dead or unconscious? Well, there's no blood, but it's a cartoon... of course there's no blood. But they've never talked about "we don't kill." They've TRIED to kill. It's a compromise, but it's easy enough to tolerate.

Whereas "we don't kill" is something we see hammered home OVER and OVER and OVER with IDW TMNT. They all discuss the "Shredder Manifesto", where Mikey is super uncomfortable with the thought of killing Shredder. SHREDDER. The guy who killed THEM in Japan.

And Raphael runs off to kill Arnold Jones, and is told by Splinter, "this is a bad thing to do, Raphael. Will it improve the situation?" And Raph says no. But later events show, UM, YES, this would have been a good thing to do. Hun causes a LOT of fvcking trouble later.

And all the Turtles bail on Splinter because he kills Darius Dun, that guy who straight up promises "I swear to you, some way, some how, I will destroy you, mutant. But not before I force you to watch your precious green monsters die slow, painful, pathetic deaths." And this is presented as a TERRIBLE thing.

So then, let's ask the question we've all asked before. "What's even the fvcking point of the Turtles carrying weapons? Things made to crack skulls and cut throats and stab chests?"

2) And the Cast
For years now, the Turtles have diminished in the IDW series. They don't ever win fights on their own; they're always calling in backup. We're always being treated to Angel and Alopex and Casey. And now we're in Mutant Town, a furry festival for shippers. Oh boy, baby Turtles! And baby weasels! And pig rock girls! And missing children! It's all so fvcking CUTE.

Not to mention that we still haven't seen Null do ANYTHING in 4 years. Or that Hob and Baxter still haven't faced off in... 6 years? I'm guessing here.

To sum my points, I've lost my love of IDW TMNT. It's moving into new territory that seems aimed at bringing in audiences who are fans of Zootopia and want to see as many mutants as possible. The Turtles are barely characters in these last issues. And while "City at War" set up some really interesting new plots, like Mayor Baxter, Shredder training the Turtles, Casey losing his dad who died saving him, Splinter being DEAD, and the Turtles dealing with a new sister... we're just fvcking around in Mutant Town, drawing a bunch of new mutants, squealing over Mona Lisa getting with Donatello, cooing over Alopex and Raphael finally kissing, and worrying about mutant kids.

Which previous incarnation of TMNT would I compare it to? I wouldn't. It's thrown in elements from all the previous TMNT iterations, but now, post #100, it seems to be driving forward into a world where the Turtles are citizens of some mutant community, mutants aren't special, and character introductions and focus seems calculated for maximum PC appeal. And I'm a fvcking LIBERAL, who wants more female characters.

I'm still reading. But I don't enjoy it. And I'm very, very close to walking away for good. My thinking right now is collect up to #100 in the hardbacks. And if the ongoing story hasn't brought me back by the time that last hardback is on my bookshelf, I'm gone for good.
__________________
ALL THEIR DAYS ARE NUMBERED
CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy is offline   Reply With Quote