I already said that, though. I already said that I was allowing for the fact that #100 was an outlier because Milestone issues always skew high.
The fact remains that if we assume that all 50,000+ people who bought #100 actually read it - and that IS assuming quite a lot, but for the sake of argument let's assume they did read it and not just toss it in a box - then fewer than half of those people were intrigued enough to come back the next month and buy the following issue(s).
To relate it to something I have a more personal hand and experience in, look at a "Milestone" issue of a comic book as similar to a Free Trial Gym Membership. You know that your "promotion" is going to draw more eyes to the product as a matter of course, get people in the door, but KEEPING them is the ultimate goal. You know for a fact that you're not going to have 100% retention, BUT, the more people you keep, the better. If you advertise that you're going to give away 50 Free Passes, and it turns out 100 people ask for one and you end up doing 100 Free Passes, that seems good on the surface because there's more interest than you expected there to be. But if only TWO of those 100 people decide to actually join the gym, then guess what? You didn't gain anything. That means 98 out of 100 people all said "Eh, this isn't for me", and you failed in your ultimate goal. At this point is when the owners and management call a meeting and ask you why you "failed", and discussions begin about what needs to change (and who's not going to have a job very soon, because someone always has to fall on a sword). Believe me, I'm quite familiar with those kinds of scenarios.
So five times the regular "viewing audience" for TMNT decided to look at #100, but they failed to gain ANY new readers out of that and furthermore lost a big chunk of those who had been reading the previous six months. Even if we admit that any milestone issue is an outlier with an artificially high sales number, it's STILL an opportunity for sustained growth. And they didn't grow in readers in the aftermath, they shrunk.
One HAS to assume that wouldn't be the case if more people than not actually liked what they saw. That's all I'm trying to say.
Quote:
Originally Posted by skylord
I'm not going to argue against the base sales of TMNT being pretty poor. I don't know IDWs benchmarks and can't really comment on what they consider good sales. Just looking at trends, regular readership has never been all that high and if anything I'd take the fact that it's lasted this long as a sign that it will stick around for a while. Ultimately like most long running series with a plot focus it will have to end.
|
I'd agree on some level with this, although you can bet for sure that they wish they were selling more. It can't be a good feeling to know that on any given month, a ton of books nobody's ever heard of sell three times as many copies. I thought TMNT was this "evergreen" phenomenon and really, REALLY popular? Facts don't support that thesis. Not when they can't outsell Conan, or occasionally My Little Pony.