View Single Post
Old 03-18-2021, 10:50 PM   #8
Zog The Magnificent
Stone Warrior
 
Zog The Magnificent's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2015
Posts: 830
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
But how exactly do you remove Nagi without stripping Saki of reasonable motives and sympathy points??
  1. If Saki just betrays Yoshi for power, he's just power hungry.
  2. If he kills Yoshi and Shen out of envy, he's just a psycho.
  3. If he kills them because they're traitors to the Clan, he's just following duty.
  4. If he kills Shen and blames Yoshi, he's a delusional tool.
  5. If he kills Yoshi because he failed to interrogate him, Yoshi is just a casualty of Shredder thinking tactically.

These cases either negate any sympathy for Shredder or it removes his emotional involvement almost entirely. Again, these changes were not in place to make a better character dynamic, they were made to make Shredder seem more evil. That is the entire point of the opening post, remove Nagi and you remove what little makes you feel sorry for Shredder.

"You killed my brother" is a very common trope but it is effective. And I'm not sure why you don't think that is especially personal, kill someone's family member and they're going to take it personally.
I don't actually think that making him more evil is necessarily a bad thing. In some ways, I'm actually pretty tired of the general tendency that every villain has to be sympathetic or have some sort of elaborate tragic backstory. I miss the days of classic villains. Sometimes, I think it's okay to have a villain who is just evil because he's an a**hole. There are plenty of people like that in real life, and the point of a villain is to serve as the focal point and driving force behind the conflict. While it can result in a shallower villain, in the hands of a good writer there can still be a good story. I think a good example of this is Avatar: The Last Airbender. At the end of the day, Ozai is not a super deep character. He's evil because he's a douche and he wants power. The deeper characterization is afforded to Zuko and Azula. Even in Star Wars, Palpatine is not a super deep chracter in terms of his motivation, but he works great as a villain and as a consequence is one of the best parts about the franchise.

Regardless of that, and to answer your question, I think we can look at the IDW Shredder. Here is a case wherein Oroku Nagi is removed and the rivalry is between Splinter and Shredder. Shredder himself is just as evil as he always is, but he still has honorable qualties and is in part driven by outside forces that corrupted him, best shown in the contrast of his first death wherein he took the chance to accept seppuku as opposed to his Mirage counterpart. Beyond that, the character is sympathetic enough to the point that he got a bona fide redemption arc and is now on the side of the heroes. Without Oroku Nagi, he still managed to be just as evil, as well as ultimately sympathetic and a fully realized character.

As a separate point, I will also cite the 2012 Shredder, though I realize I may lose some points as it seems that show is not held in as high regard here. I will admit that the 2012 cartoon is my favorite of the cartoons, and despite the fact that the Shredder is less sympathetic, I think it still works really well. In this case, he is driven by rage and delusion, an inabilty to take responsibility for his part in things. This consumes him over the course of the show, as he gradually loses it and comes to sacrifice everything he has for the sake of a singular goal that he doesn't even have the right to be angry about in the first place, until it eventually gets him killed. It works because the story was never about him; it was about the turtles and Splinter. The story doesn't need us to root for him or even sympathize with him because he at the end of the day serves as an antagonist for our heroes, with the story being about how they react and deal with it. In that role, he serves very well as a villain and pushes the narrative forward, and in doing so pushes forward the development of our heroes. As a villain, he's quite good. In both cases Oroku Nagi was not present, and it didn't make the Shredder any less interesting of a chracter, because he played his role in the story well, and in the context of that story served it. It's sort of like the Utrom Shredder in that regard. I liked him for who he was within the context of the 2003 show, but I wouldn't want to see him in other shows because I don't think he'd work for other shows. For these reasons, I believe that Oroku Nagi is redundant, and that this doesn't necessarily have to affect the quality of the character of Shredder, as well as the idea that being more evil is necessarily a bad thing depending on the context of the new universe.

(edit): I should add, because I don't think I actually addressed it, but it's not that one's brother being killed isn't personal, it's that it makes it slightly less personal by adding a second step to the rivalry that could be just between the two men. From TMNT Entity, "I mean, I can see why most adaptations (such as the movies and the current IDW comic) cut him out; it makes for just as strong a revenge theme to have Oroku Saki be the one to menace Tang Shen from the get-go than to create an older brother character to menace her, then have Yoshi kill him, then have Saki swear vengeance, then have Saki kill them both" (Pellegrini, 2012). In addition, it further dilutes the origin because it never comes up agagin. Shredder never brings up Oroku Nagi, and it seems by all accounts that he had no impact on his life. You get the sense that this is the sort of thing he would be doing anyways and that he didn't really need the "excuse" of his brother getting killed to act. The fact that it never informs any part of his character afterward is also what I feel makes the case for his exclusion, as he isn't much more than a prop to get the plot going. You could have replaced it with another event and it would ultimately have had the same impact both from a narrative and character standpoint.

Last edited by Zog The Magnificent; 03-18-2021 at 11:21 PM.
Zog The Magnificent is offline   Reply With Quote