Quote:
Originally Posted by superstaff
Not sure why you assume I and others who've criticized these comics are 'perpetually miserable'. It's funny because the ones I see insulting people here are the supporters of the comics.
Criticism is important, and yes, there is a difference between legitimate criticism and bashing. There's many ways to discern the difference between the two as well, and not everyone is out to 'get' the creators when they air their grievances with a story.
As a writer myself, I try to take criticism into account. Sometimes I get reviews that feel uncalled for, and sometimes I get reviews that criticize my weaknesses in writing (ex: I have trouble describing things in detail sometimes), and the negative reviews always make me ponder ways I can improve. Yes, even the troll-ish ones.
Anyway, as I said before, I've felt my interest in the IDW comics waning for a while now, and I'll likely just drop the comic, and just read stuff I do like (which is becoming a smaller pool, sadly). There's nothing wrong with that.
|
((Raises Hand)) I'm generally quite jolly.

I guarantee you I laugh a lot more in Real Life than any of these miserable pricks do.
Here's the thing: I write stuff, too, but I am aware that what I write wouldn't "sell". Therefore, I don't ask people to pay me $4 a month for it. I keep it as a hobby.
It would be very arrogant of me to charge people money for my work, and then if they tell me "Here's what I don't like, I'm not going to buy it anymore unless you fix it," tell them
they're the problem and that I'll be fine if they don't buy it. Like yeah, I'll be fine, so long as I don't wanna eat.
When Last Ronin is setting sales records that no TMNT comic before has ever come close to... it blows my mind that the IDW monthly can slump along with numbers that would absolutely get any other book cancelled and yet the diehards insist that "Everything Is Roses." It's not.
Quote:
Originally Posted by hypered1
I think it's also worth pointing out 2 things, 1: #100 and TLR naturally had higher sales because of the farfare and advertising they got and 2: any sales figures from last year are going to be much lower because of the pandemic as much as if not more so than a natural reader drop-off; people aren't going to buy things they don't need especially if they've lost there job and there's no denying that unemployment rates are way higher than they were before both in the US and here in the UK.
|
130,000 copies for Last Ronin. DURING the pandemic.
Yes, speculators for issue #100 and the effects of the pandemic are factors.
But they don't dilute the rest of the story.
1. They lost 40,000 people overnight because people don't want Zootopia Lite fanfic in their TMNT comics. Again, if they'd managed to keep monthly sales above, say, 25,000, I wouldn't think much of it. But they didn't just lose "a few speculators" after issue #100, they lost EVERYONE except the diehards, the people who will buy the book no matter what. And diehards don't keep a book afloat forever.
2. Last Ronin, again, sold HUGE numbers despite all of those pandemic factors.
It's the CONTENT that's the problem.
People don't WANT this. If they wanted it, they'd BUY it. YOU like it. Alright. TigerClaw likes it. Okay. The numbers are still terrible and other books ARE selling. And unless the two of you are gonna each buy the extra 10,000 copies per month to keep the book afloat, please do not cry if it gets cancelled sooner rather than later.
Again, I am not hoping for the book to be cancelled. I am simply saying, any other book would have been long before now, and the fact that Last Ronin blew the monthly book out of the water means that people can't just make excuses anymore for why the monthly book doesn't sell.
People don't want what the monthly book has to offer. That's it, and that's all. It can't be spun. People want a TMNT book... but not THAT one. It's very, very cut-and-dry.
It's Mirage Vol. 4 all over again. TMNT isn't super-popular, but kinda-popular. People didn't buy Vol. 4 because they didn't like it. They wanted a TMNT book, just not THAT one. Same thing Here and Now.