Thread: Modern IDW
View Single Post
Old 03-24-2021, 12:15 PM   #5
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
Why have them be ninjas, if they are not going to be doing Ninja Things?

It's the same sh*t when people say that their favorite thing about super-hero comics isn't when they do Super-Hero things, it's when they're cracking jokes over Starbucks coffee or standing in line at the bank. "Just like us!" Because most people totally, totally wanna read about THAT stuff in a comic where things like alien invasions, cross-dimensional chaos and people who bench-press planets and shoot eye-lasers are a reality. Let's do NONE of that, and have lots and lots of panels of them doing laundry and taking their pets to the vet. That Sells.

Likewise, TMNT has so many fantastical elements that it seems like a waste to not lean into them, while instead focusing entirely on the mundane.

You can absolutely do "slice of life" and when done well, it enriches the more fantastical elements rather than working against them. But this doesn't even feel like "TMNT" anymore. It's like they're just guest stars in a story that wasn't written about them and has no idea what to actually do with them.

There's a germ of a good idea in all of what's been done. I just think the execution hasn't been great and it seems like most people agree. If it were more of an action story and less of a "cutesy" drama/comedy with crammed-in Real-Life political overtones, I think it would be more well-received.

As I've said elsewhere, it's like why Mirage Vol. 4 failed. Not inherently a "bad" story, but absolutely not at ALL what a TMNT comic "should have" been if it actually wanted to grab people by the throat and make them read it.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote