Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656
The toys are one thing. We'll see if the game moves the needle in any appreciable way, or if it'll be like so many other of these "throwback" games that get "old schoolers" hard but don't have any impact otherwise.
You bring up "collected editions" over and over as if that's something incredibly relevant, though, and I kinda don't think it is. I mean, it's nice that they even bother, sure. But at the same time, I don't think that it makes any sense to trumpet something that essentially says, "Look how cool this brand USED to be" as indicative of how good things supposedly are NOW.
In fact, ALL of those "good things" are more exercises in nostalgia more than anything. The NECA toys are based on the only good TMNT movie along with "the only TMNT cartoon anyone remembers". The Super 7 toys are "do-overs" of stuff we already bought 30 years ago, just with a modern spin. The collected editions are just a reminder that the TMNT comics didn't always suck. The upcoming game is - once again - based on a cartoon (and a gameplay style) that's more than 30 years old.
When the best this brand can do is remind you how much better things were 30+ years ago... that is an admission of defeat. "We can't create New Things of quality, so let us serve you re-heated nostalgia instead."
And that's fine. The toys are cool enough, the game might be good, whatever... it's absolutely fine to enjoy those things for what they are and it's good that they exist. But ideally, there should be things to look forward to that DON'T require looking exclusively to the past. But that's all this franchise can do anymore, because when the Powers-That-Be try and come up with "new ideas", we get BayTurtles, "Rise", and Mutant Town.
This franchise isn't "alive"; it's a zombie, that only appears to simulate life because it has jumper cables jammed into every available orifice. But there is no "life"; just constant reminders that "30 years ago, this brand was the Hottest Thing Going".
Yeah. 30 years ago. Not now, and never, ever again.
It's depressing. Forget 1990 Nostalgia; I'd settle for 2003-ish nostalgia, when there were still only a few TMNT "universes" and MOST of them didn't suck. Think about THAT, for a second; we'll never, ever again be able to say "There's more Good TMNT than Bad TMNT." MOST TMNT product is garbage, and it would take a series of minor miracles to ever swing things back the other way.
Maybe that doesn't bother some folks, but it sure bothers me.
|
Doesn't seem like all nostalgia to me. The Last Ronin is exactly what plenty of older fans have been asking for. It's nostalgic, only in the sense, that it's coming directly from the roots of the franchise, which is as good as it gets for some of us. TMNT started as a gritty, goofy, indie comic. Having the creator back doing what made the world fall in love with the franchise in the first place? That's a best case scenario, in my eyes. That's the cream of the crop. Hard to call the franchise dead when that is alive, beating, and proving the franchise has more life in it, if you just lift up the right rock.
TMNT has been the biggest story in comics over the last year. Not just in page content, but in attention. Every comic podcast is talking turtles, all the sales charts are lit up with turtles. Back issues have quadrupled in price. People care and are talking about TMNT. Feels like it has a pulse, when you look at it that way.
I don't buy the argument that "it's only a few issues." To me, that sounds like moving the goal post.
Yeah, it just started. It's current. That's okay, it speaks even more to the point that way. The franchise can't be dead if new, fresh projects have just begun.
And they're chunky issues, with more on the way.
Some of the other stuff is more nostalgia-based, sure, but that stuff is quality and has reason to exist. People like it. That's a good thing.
The mirage reprints have been awesome because they were something we had a very hard time getting when Mirage owned the license.
Same with the figures - the brand is being treated better than ever, figure-wise, so even if it is nostalgia, it's something fans have been dying for, and it's actually aimed at longtime fans, which is great.
The game is a throwback to an older style of game, but they got beloved developers to make it. It's a good thing.
I see your point. A lot of it is nostalgia based, but the nostalgia-based products are great, and fans love them. And, again, it's really not all nostalgia-based - you have the last ronin. Maybe TLR doesn't cut it for you, but when it's lighting the comic world on fire, calling it dead seems willfully ignorant. Sure, the comic world isn't huge, but when tmnt is selling more than Batman and X-Men #1's...it ain't dead.