Alright:
- Vol 1
- Tales Vol 1
- Tales Vol 2
- Vol 2
- Image
And Vol 4 is N/A, simply because there is no good way for me to collect it.
I should point out here that I don't think any of the TMNT books that were ongoings don't have serious problems, aside from maybe Tom Waltz run on IDW. Not that they are bad books, just that I can very easily see what doesn't quite work about them.
I mostly just rank these based on how many stories that I consider good (or good enough) are found in them. Vol 2 and Image are put on the bottom because both essentially only have one or two stories each and I don't consider any of them to be a particularly good one.