View Single Post
Old 08-27-2021, 05:07 AM   #4
Zog The Magnificent
Stone Warrior
 
Zog The Magnificent's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2015
Posts: 830
Here's my ranking.

1. Vol. 1 (And I'm including Tales Vol.1 with this)
2. Vol. 3
3. Vol. 4
4. Tales Vol. 2
5. Vol. 2

Volume 1 really was the peak of Mirage storytelling. The story continually built upon itself, the stakes rose, the characters all grew and changed, and the main narrative was conclusively wrapped up by the end. Tales volume 1 is so short and so intertwined with Volume 1 that I personally don't see the point in counting it as separate. Mirage vol. 1 took the characters as far as they could go, and no one really figured out what to do with them in this universe after the fact. There are plenty of good stories after the fact, but they never came together with that sense of build up or narrative like they did with Volume 1.

That being said, Image Vol. 3 is a close second for me. The Image run, especially with the conclusions that now exist, is the only other story that has all of the elements that made Volume 1 so good, albeit drenched in a bit of 90s cheese. Despite being a product of its time, I really enjoyed it, as well as it's willingness to break the status quo and actually develop the characters in ways that were organic to their characterizations in the previous volumes. Plus, I just think it had a lot of cool ideas and some great and consistent artwork to go along with it.

Volume 2 is easily the worst of the bunch. Not only is it way too short, but it has a meandering story that ultimately goes nowhere. It starts off with all these great ideas, and then immediately sidelines all of them for badly drawn action, bad plotting and characters, and especially bad pacing. The whole thing starts off slow before kicking into high gear and ramming into a wall at 200 mph by the end. Also, it has what is perhaps one of the worst uses of the "As you know" trope. You know the scene I'm talking about.

After that, the middle of the list is somewhat arbitrary. Ultimately, Volume 4 is higher for me because it's a serialized narrative and I just prefer that sort of storytelling. There are a lot of individual good issues in Tales vol. 2, but as a whole it's still just an anthology with a lot really great issues mixed in with a bunch of mediocre issues, and a lot of subplots that never got the followup they needed. There are a lot of excellent stories in that run that I would rank over Volume 4 perhaps, but as a whole I have to place it lower. Volume 4 had the same problem, but at least it was interesting before it started losing track of the plot and then petering out. Even though Volume 4 doesn't have an ending, it's still better than the trainwreck that Volume 2 ended up turing into.
Zog The Magnificent is offline   Reply With Quote