View Single Post
Old 09-30-2021, 07:13 PM   #2
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
Oh, man, this is actually tough. I mean, both Mirage Vol. 4 (while being "pure" in the sense that at least it's the franchise creator's own personal vision) and the post-100 IDW run are about as far from what most TMNT fans would ever want to read as it gets, albeit from different directions. It's also tough to pick between them, since Vol. 4 will never have an ending and the current IDW run SEEMS like it's never going to end, so it's tough to grade either one of them "A-to-Z" since at present, neither of them has a "Z". They do both have a similar problem in that it takes dozens of issues for nothing of any importance to happen.

For me, they both scrape the bottom and are stuff I can't see myself looking at again.

I also didn't care for the Image run back in the day, but I confess that it's been so long since I've looked at it my opinion may shift if I'm ever inclined to go back to it. Peoples' collective opinions on it seem to have softened; when I was new to the internet, the consensus seemed to be that it was among the worst TMNT material in existence, BUT to be fair at that time there wasn't a ton of TMNT media that was considered to be bad. So maybe people overreacted. I see a lot more people praising it Now than I ever did back Then. For my part, it seemed very, very "try-hard" back then, like it was going out of its way to be "edgy" and the antithesis of what TMNT had become. Which was perhaps necessary, but in reading it I could never shake the idea that the writers were rubbing their hands together and cackling with glee at the prospective reaction to things like the Turtles getting mutilated. Like shock value was the main drive behind it. Maybe it was, maybe it wasn't; I don't know, I'll give it another look one day now that it has an ending.

I wouldn't call it a "run" but most of those guest artist issues of Mirage Vol. 1 were pretty damn brutal, too.

I can't really cast a vote right now. I will say, I wish it was one of those polls that revealed who voted for what. I demand accountability so that I can continue to judge people based on their entertainment preferences.

Not at all shocked by what's currently in the "lead", though.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote