View Single Post
Old 10-08-2021, 11:21 PM   #34
Leo656
Banned
 
Leo656's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: nWo Country
Posts: 27,703
Nah, I pretty much only ever rip on Lawson and Liefeld.

There's tons of comic book artists I don't like, for whatever reason. But those are the only two where I've ever been thrown for a loop that they actually get paid for what they do. Thus, why they're the only two I really ever bother to comment on.

There's "This just isn't for me," but at some point, there's also, "I just can't even believe this is real." That's where I'm at with those two. Although Liefeld has shown SOME improvement over the years, whereas it can be argued (and has been, by many people who aren't me) that Lawson actually regressed quite a bit as time went on.

As for what kind of art I'd prefer for TMNT... my answer to that would basically be, "Just about anyone else who ever worked on it." Just being honest.

I mean, you can have a "style" and be "memorable" but still have your art look like... what it's supposed to look like. Freddie Williams II, for example, is fairly "stylized" in a manner of speaking, but it doesn't look like something a kid hastily scrawled on their notebook during study hall. He's done some TMNT stuff, and I'd gladly take that kind of thing every day forever. Ed McGuinness is another guy who does "Stylized" art that's still pretty good, and also "memorable" and "impactful".

I certainly have been "impacted" by Lawson's TMNT art. But mostly in the sense of, every time I see it, I wish I was looking at something else. I'd rather be impacted in a positive way.

I am aware that, within the TMNT fandom, this is a highly unpopular opinion.

I am also aware, however, that outside of the "TMNT fandom", it IS a fairly popular opinion. There has always been a strong consensus among the various comic shop owners I've spoken to, for example, that the TMNT books he draws do not sell very well in part because they are not pleasing to look at. From their perspective, his artwork effects their bottom line because people would pick up the books, say "Damn, this is ugly," and put it down. What I have always, always heard, is that "People want to buy a TMNT comic, but not one that isn't pleasing to look at. If they don't like the art, they don't buy the book." To be fair, the fact that most of the TMNT comics he's drawn were black and white did not help, as that definitely ruined sales as well, over the years. And granted, this is all anecdotal. But it's always been a prevalent sentiment in my state, and I do not live in a vacuum, thus I am willing to assume that it has been the case elsewhere as well, probably exponentially.

Anyway, the other dude brought him up. I just jumped on.
Leo656 is offline   Reply With Quote