Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
But again, pointing to Volume 2 as anything seems like weak sauce. You can't compare it to Vol. 1 or even 3 or 4 to any extent. It's 13 issues that were just beginning to go somewhere in a very decompressed storyline before they had to stop and truncate things very suddenly.
|
Why? It doesn't matter why it ended up sucking, just that it did. Even if there were reasons behind it, knowing those reasons doesn't change the fact that the final product is not a good comic. The fact is is that it exists, it has a complete beginning, middle, and ending, and can thus be judged on it's own merits as any other story and artistic work that has been created. If it had just been cancelled and left unresolved, then you would have a point. But they chose to rush the issues they had left and haphazardly "resolve" it. It's longer than many miniseries which only go on for 4 to 6 issues, and those are judged as singluar units. Heck, it's even longer than Watchmen, and that's judged as it's own work. Even if we know why it ended up mediocre, at the end of the day, it's still mediocre and was put out into the world that way, and we can thus talk about it and compare it to other things.