View Single Post
Old 10-09-2021, 11:25 AM   #43
Zog The Magnificent
Stone Warrior
 
Zog The Magnificent's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2015
Posts: 830
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
But it's unfair. By Vol. 3's truncated ending they were able to complete... several story arcs. Vol. 2's structure didn't even have story arcs... just a free-flowing decompressed narrative that just suddenly ended. So technically they didn't even get to finish even 1.

Again, not apples to apples.
Volume 2 has three very clear arcs: The initial aftermath of Vol. 1, the return of Baxter Stockman, and the Attack on DARPA, with a short interlude arc in the middle involving the return of the Fish People and Leo's emotional state. Each one of them is foreshadowed in the previous arcs (except the Fish one), each one of them concludes, and the story ends with all of them safe and sound back at April's. Technically, they did finish the three (or four) story arcs that they had. They just didn't do it well. And again, just because they were truncated, that doesn't excuse the bad writing. Those individual elements didn't have to be bad. The first two were fine, but the Fish people story just undermines "Sons of the Silent Age," and the DARPA arc is a big rushed mess with cheap character deaths, dull action, and Casey being brainwashed into an action hero for no reason. They could have done something better with the short time that they had. It didn't have to suck outside of being rushed. It didn't have to be poorly written. But it was, and it was concluded, and put out into the world that way. That makes it fair game as far as any discussion goes. I don't really think it's not apples to apples. After Volume 1, Mirage never really finished or properly pay off any of their longer stories. This is just the first instance of it. And, as far as the writing goes, it ends up being really similar to the way Volume 4 was ultimately handled. A lot of interesting ideas, followed by a lot of decompression, followed by an unsatisfying conclusion. But at least Vol. 2 technically has an ending. Volume 4, like Volume 3 originally before it, just stops right in the middle. I think the comparison is quite apt.

Last edited by Zog The Magnificent; 10-09-2021 at 11:34 AM.
Zog The Magnificent is offline   Reply With Quote