Quote:
Originally Posted by Leo656
Yeah, but as MOTU Revelation proved, you do that and then you get people screaming about how it's "terrible" because it's not as light, fluffy and one-dimensional as the original show was.
But as I've oft-argued in defense of Revelation, if you DO try and do a show/movie/etc. that's 1:1 with the original, you'd get the ten to twenty people who remain in romantic love with that older version without irony to love it, and everyone else would think it was the dumbest thing ever that nobody thought to aim higher 30+ years later.
Sometimes, you really just can't win. Try and raise the stakes a bit, you get chastised for "ruining the innocence" of the original. Stick 1:1 with the original aesthetic, you get chastised for being out of touch and not having any new ideas.
|
I don't disagree with any of this (and agree with you that the first movie is the sweet spot they should really be aiming for rather than FW).
I do think that
if they go in this direction it will avoid the worst of the Revelation backlash as you won't have the whole "it's about Teela" thing. They'll probably do something similar to the 2007 movie and say April has been training so she can be a more active character, but the focus would be clearly on the turtles (and they don't have to worry about Netflix splitting the story in half either).
That said, I think it will be guilty of not raising the stakes, since it will be aimed more at kids. Which will also be the studio response to any adult fans' criticism. So less backlash, but also less point in doing it in the first place. Like you say, damned if you do, damned if you don't.
Let's be honest, if they do a FW "sequel" aimed at kids it's essentially being made for a new kids but with a nostalgia wrapper to loosely appeal to their parents. If we get something that all ages can truly enjoy (like the best Disney and Pixar stuff), that manages to hit the nostalgia button whilst offering something new I will be genuinely amazed. But, since they seem determined to avoid doing anything aimed at adults or drawing from Mirage, it's still a better idea than what they tried with 2014 and Rise.