|
Adherence to the source material doesn't mean anything when it comes to the quality of the adaptation.
It is kind of strange to think that "closeness to the source material" is more important than quality of the work as a whole.
And in general, adaptation, should always stand on its own.
If adaptation needs support of the source material to be understood or to be considered a "good adaptation", than this adaptation is trash. Simple as that.
And this is the prime case with WB movies as of late - no matter how close they are to the tone of contemporary comic books, it doesn't make them good, because, quality of writing sucks.
|