Freddy vs. Jason wasn't listed as an option, Andrew.
I suppose there's no law in saying where it ranks for you. And I somehow knew you would.
But it wasn't listed as an option! 
I'd honestly rank that one pretty low. Maybe not "low" but no higher than the middle of the pack. It does exactly what it sets out to do. But as an actual "movie"... it is so... so... SO f*cking dumb. To the point where I have to be in the mood for it. If I'm not in the proper mindset, I cannot help but mercilessly rip that movie apart for its unrepentant stupidity, combined with the fact that if we're being perfectly honest, you could probably take a bunch of random script pages and throw them in a sorting machine and get a better script than the one that movie actually had. It would not be at all difficult to write a much, MUCH better Freddy vs. Jason movie.
On the flip side... couple'a awesome tit shots in that one. Can't lie about that.