Quote:
Originally Posted by Sumac
FW TMNT and ENG work in different genres - ENG meant to be straight up comedy-musical movie, whereas TMNT were meant to be much simpler TV series with some action elements. Thus writers goal were quite different from each other, thus this comparison is off the mark and invalid.
|
No, it's a basic example of how a contradiction can be used for a joke. It applies to anything that intends to be a comedy, be it a movie or a TV show. If there isn't an actual joke attached to the contradiction, it's just a contradiction.
You pointed out that trying to judge the quality of the scripts of TMNT is like pointing out plotholes in Hot Shots. This is an example how you can judge the quality of a comedy.
If you want another example, when there is an animation error in the Fred Wolf show, that's clearly just an error because it doesn't tie into any joke. This scene from Spaceballs where Dark Helmet accidentally kills a cameraman is clearly still a joke because... Well, they didn't just happen to get a shot of the secondary camera team, it plays into the scene:
You can't just deflect criticisms about errors because the show is a comedy, nor can you claim it doesn't need to construct a joke properly because it isn't entirely a comedy. You need to argue that the jokes aren't just errors or argue why they aren't errors in the first place.
Quote:
Originally Posted by FredWolfLeonardo
You're not completely wrong here, but being able to untie knots and move around on a few wheels is on a whole another level of effort as compared to building an android body and operating machinery.
I mean, the show is not super complex or anything, but I feel like these criticisms are far too nitpicky. The average viewer will probably criticise the animation and dated humour which I think is fair, but these contradictions aren't really contradictions in the first place, atleast not in any significant way that makes the show unwatchable or completely nonsensical.
|
The scene I am talking about shows us that Krang has left the Technodrome, entered a street level building and presumably left it before it collapsed a few minutes later. How do you think he did that? Either he operated a vehicle that brought him to the surface or he climbed there under his own power. And as I already mentioned, the Technodrome is capable of constructing robots as long it is provided a blue print, so why does he need someone else's hands if we know he's strong enough to push a button?
This isn't a nitpick because the premise of the season is that Krang is helpless without a body but Shredder is reluctant to help him out, and the scene in particular is important because it moves the plot along. It is a serious issue because the show broke the premise of the plot to further the plot.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sumac
I am not really what it had to do with punchlines, because, it is complaint about continuity more like. And continuity was never top priority for FW show. It barely existed and there is a bunch of contradictions, thanks to different writers doing their own thing, while ignoring each other works.
Once again FW TMNT wasn't meant to be big on a continuity.
You have different sense of humor. Its OK.
I do like those jokes, so?
Different strokes for different folks and all that.
|
Continuity is important on some level if you want to tell a coherent story. You might be able to argue that it is not important between episodes (I'll get back to that) but within the same episode? No, maybe as a joke but not otherwise. The example with the MOUSER episode has a scene where Krang complains about not having a body and how he can't do anything without one, again, the same episode where he can somehow leave and return to the Technodrome unnoticed. It's not like how one episode depicted Krang's species as disembodied brain creatures and then dozens of episodes later they were giant lizards, the same exact episode is inconsistent about what he is and isn't able to without a body.
As for continuity between episodes, there must be some level where you actually care, right? "The Principal and the Pauper" is one of the most hated episodes of the Simpsons, precisely because it breaks continuity with previous episodes and despite the Simpsons generally disregarding continuity anyway. The premise of Principal Skinner as a character is that he was raised by a verbally abusive mother and sergeant in Vietnam, which is why he behaves the way he does. According to "The Principal and the Pauper" that backstory was a lie, which didn't make sense to anyone.
So if the Fred Wolf show retconned Splinter's backstory to make him Yoshi's pet rat instead of Yoshi himself, would you be OK with that? I doubt it.
And I'm not really going to go into why a joke can be poorly constructed here, the post might get too long.