Quote:
Originally Posted by Sumac
I think, and maybe I am mistaking about it, you are a bit too obsessed with an idea, that everything about FW TMNT is bad. Which is not the case.
|
Well, no
everything about the show is bad but the problem is that it quite often fails do basic fundamentals rights.
Yes, that's a plothole or at least not explained story element.
But I don't it hurts series a lot for reasons stated below.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sumac
Not really.
FW TMNT is choke full of "negative" continuity, where a lot of things contradict each other even in the span of the same season, not to mention the whole series. Two Atlantis? Splinter being leader of the Foot Clan, despite being mere pupil and kicked out even before he could reach any notable position (talking about Splinter being a human or a rat)? Characters who appear out of nowhere and act like they were always there?
I mean, arguing that FW TMNT has any solid continuity is a strange and macabre waste of time. Even worse arguing that people should be up in arms about it. As a kid I saw all this story issues and I didn't care since I watched show for something different: good jokes and fun interactions between characters.
My position regarding this show hasn't changed - its continuity is barely existing, its choke full of holes and contradictions and I like it that way, since I like it for something different.
If you want to complain about series with continuity issues, you can look at 2k3 series, which didn't had guts to stuck with Utrom Shredder and felt necessity to "redeem" itself and introduce Demon and Human Shredders, cheapening Ch'rell in the process.
This is where it matters.
In FW this stuff does not.
|
I'm sorry but this really just comes across like "because they didn't care, we shouldn't either and therefore it's not a problem". It is a problem because even if the show was episodic, there is still some things that carry over from previous episodes and some semblance of a storyline.
And even if we say continuity between episodes don't matter, when it's argued that Krang should be allowed to do things he explicitly says he can't do in the same episode, that is the same as arguing that a 20 minute episode can have a serious internal contradiction and be perfectly fine.
And I ask you again, is there really nothing that this show could have done to break your immersion? Let's be even more explicit here, if the show had totally just retconned Splinter's season 1 backstory and replaced it with the Mirage backstory, would you not have called BS? If the show suddenly decided Bebop and Rocksteady were aliens rather than Mutants, what would your reaction have been like? What if April's occupation randomly changed from being a reporter to a computer programmer and it was treated like she had never been a reporter, would that seem right to you? I know none of that actually happened but you make it seem as if the show could go to any extreme break in continuity and you'd be fine with it. So if any of that happened would you be fine with it? And if not, what is the most extreme change you could have accepted?
Quote:
Originally Posted by FredWolfLeonardo
I think the most simple and sensible explanation is that a Foot Soldier carried him there and back. I dont think that breaks the plot in any significant way.
The Technodrome also just can't create a machine on its own, the mousers could only be mass produced because there was a prior physical model that Baxter created first that we even see being replicated. For the android body on the other hand, there was only a drawing on paper.
|
Programming a robot to carry him around still means he had enough agency to operate machinery to some extent. It's arguably even worse because then he could just order the robot to build the body for him, which still means he has no use for Shredder.
And the idea that the factory can only create robots if it first scans a pre-existing prototype is really weird. It would imply the machine is able to build all the parts from scratch and assemble them automatically, but can't do so unless someone else did it first. Factories in real life don't really have that limitation, why would a fictional factory using advanced alien tech have it? If Krang had the blueprints to build his robotic body and Technodrome had or could construct the parts needed, then the factory should suffice.