View Single Post
Old 07-19-2022, 07:21 PM   #91
Cipher
Foot Elite
 
Cipher's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 3,454
Lmao, you guys.

So, I read the second volume of the Campbell run, #106-110, since it was free with Kindle Unlimited. As prep, I also read through about half of the IDW Collection #12, since it was also included, just so I had a little chunk of the later Waltz era for comparison.

Quick praise for the the 12th collection: I was pleasantly surprised by and really enjoyed Ian Flynn's Michelangelo one-shot and Ryan Ferrier's Mutagen Man-Mondo two-parter in Universe. The main book issues included let me kind of cold, but I didn't have any context and they were plot-heavy, so I don't think I can respond fairly to them. (Feeling extremely plot heavy with scant character moments was one of the things that got me to eventually drop the book, but things may have changed and this was just the wrong spot to drop in. Or not, and anyway, to each their own.)

For the Campbell issues ... this was what the fuss was about?

I enjoyed them a lot more than I had most of IDW when I was reading it, but I'm still not sure it's my thing. I do like that we have more downtime, and the interesting roles it's put characters like the Turtles Hob into though (the issue with him where the weasels sneak in really piqued my interest, and the weasels themselves are also great, even though I have no idea what's up with them). I also got a chuckle here and there, out of bits like the Koya-Karai-Bludgeon scene, the weasels and Hob, and a few other sections. It feels like it's really doing something new, even though the "remember X?" reliance in certain spots still got me. It's IDW.

Anyway, here's the tally on what people told me was too woke about it, or too different from whatever previous Turtles books have done:

--------------

Touching on real-world issues: Five pages.
  • Alopex and Mona discuss how the government isn't looking out for them, which could be read as an allusion to governments failing marginalized communities in general. One page. Ripe for commentary, but in this case it's also an immediate setup for discussing more Mutant Town government establishment talk, which is a natural avenue for storytelling and I'm guessing something for future plot points?
  • Michelangelo watches talking heads inaccurately discuss mutants on the news, and then a reporter asks him weird mating questions before even getting his name. Two pages. Yeah, that's probably a trans allegory, huh? But it's a good one and germane to the characters and setting. If you don't want to read it as one, incidentally, you don't have to, as it fits right into the plot without being overt or didactic at all, which was a mode Mirage and Archie hardly ever turned to for their real-world topics, much as I love them and their bluntness. If you want to just read it as a beat for Michelangelo's motivation you can, but if you want to put two and two together on discussing groups in media without their representation or immediately asking about people's junk not being great, that's there too. I was told this was the unsubtle one. What about this is less subtle than Laird plucking far-right-wing rhetoric for villains, greenhouse-gas futures, Radical waxing about industrialization next to neon buffalo signs, or Jagwar taking a moment to shout about deforestation mid-action, I'm not sure.
  • Mona fails to earn her parents' sympathies over a video call. Two pages. Yeah, that's a trans allegory. See above.

    Also, Michelangelo being inspired by that encounter to start his own radio show is interesting and just a decent, human story angle. I like that. It's not really a political allegory at all, unless championing the power of humanistic journalism and storytelling counts as one. Makes good use of his character.

LGBT characters: Two.
  • The only characters' whose sexuality I know isn't straight in this five-issue volume are Jennika and her girlfriend. Are we at 60 percent yet?

Girls being invincible and guys sucking: Zero.
  • Jennika does exactly the same things in the action scenes as the other Turtles, winning or losing when the group does.
  • Raph beats a female biker in a race.
  • Later, the Turtles beat a female lemur who invades their house.
  • All other female characters: April, Mona, Alopex, Sally, Sheena, Karai, Koya ... am I missing anyone? ... don't get any action this volume.
  • So that's actually ... one instance of a girl doing the same things the rest of her all-guy group is, and two of girls losing to guys.

    Not that it would be a problem if the ratio skewed the other way, but this was the unnatural, distracting girl-power that was putting people off the book? Feminists need a better rep.

Gender/race/sexualitybending: Zero.
  • Race isn't much of a factor when the bulk of the book has become mutant animals, but all the human characters who showed up had the same skin tones as their initial appearances.
    • There've been a grand total of 2.5 instances of that in TMNT history ever, right? Two of which, Baxter in the original cartoon, and Eric Saks only very narrowly not replacing Oroku Saki in the first Bay movie, where moving non-white characters to white ones, with only Rise's April being the opposite?
  • There were no genderbent characters in these issues. I'm aware of two in the IDW book that came up during the Waltz era though, in Null and Jagwar?
  • No sexuality switches with existing characters that I saw here. At least two of the Turtles were shown/implied to be straight, and I know this April is, etc. The only two explicitly non-straight characters were new ones, which I thought was the right way to do it.

Sh*itting on the American flag and holding up a Marxist one: Zero. Y'all had me excited.

"Remember X?": Two.
  • Road Hogs
  • Tokka and Rahzar (the volume cliffhanger)

This was something I was curious about on my own, since I found so distracting in previous IDW material, where I was constantly wishing it would have the confidence to do its own thing. That feels like pandering to me, and always took/takes me out of the book, since it leads to cliffhangers and plot beats that feel like they hinge solely on recognition. I can't say if the rate of that coming up has gotten any better or worse. Two per volume feels maybe on the low side compared to the past, but still pretty high. Anyway, it's still IDW Turtles-ing.

--------------

It's ... IDW, with a little more space for unexplored character territory (the Hob direction is so good; that I'm genuinely curious about, and he was one of the best parts of the book back when I was reading it, as one of its original ones) and some touching on real-world personal/social issues at a rate of five pages per volume. Which I'd absolutely rather have than not, and which puts it more in company of previous Turtle books, but this isn't exactly dominating the content I read. Mirage circa Tales Vol. 2 and Archie would have gotten up to things far less subtle at a higher rate on that front. Again, for better or for worse.

What was there definitely did not feel like pandering; I'm sure that's stuff that's actually on Campbell's mind and that she's been through, just as Laird, Murphy and co. were getting at things near to them. And again: Five pages. One of them's hardly even an allegory.

If you don't enjoy the story direction, then obviously feel free to not enjoy it--and I can see why people who were super gung-ho on the Waltz era over any other Turtles books might not be having a great time. But the talk about this feeling more politically pandering or issue-heavy than any pre-Waltz TMNT comics is so disingenuous. I say having read all that pre-Waltz stuff up and down, and now having read this for comparison.

Oh, also ... does the mutagen work like the 1987 stuff, where it turns you into the last animal you touched? What were guys like the orca-dude and lemur-girl getting up to...?

EDIT -- Other note: I also liked the page of Sheena, Mona and Jennika sitting around drinking beer and discussing bands. That feels believable for a group of recently mutated girls, and it's the kind of moment I don't remember getting much space anywhere in at least the first 30 or so issues under Waltz + the spin-offs. I remember wanting moments like that, since it felt very all-plot all-the-time--even during the "downtime" Northampton arc.

Last edited by Cipher; 07-19-2022 at 08:31 PM.
Cipher is offline   Reply With Quote