View Single Post
Old 01-31-2023, 02:54 PM   #11
AquaParade
Banned
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 8,450
Quote:
Originally Posted by IMJ View Post
Doesn't just look uninteresting, it looks horrible.

When Marvel launched with "Iron Man", they took a 3rd or mmmaaayyybbbeee 2nd tier character and propelled him to a 1st tier household name. Because they had to. Iron Man had been in development on and off with Nick Casavetes for years - they had written assets already in place and it was the most "filmable" character Marvel had ownership of at the time because their I.P.'s were spread out everywhere.

You can't replicate that as a "formula". It just worked for a variety of reasons.
They aren't replicating Marvel's formula by launching with only B-list characters. They are doing Superman, Wonder Woman, and Batman....as well as things like The Authority and Swamp Thing.

Quote:
Originally Posted by IMJ View Post
DC should launch with their strongest characters and go no deeper than Green Lantern who is also a 3rd tier or occasionally 2nd tier DC character depending on the event.
They are. The only caveat being a couple small projects, like an animated series - big deal, leading up to Superman.

Going no deeper than Green Lantern sounds lame. Why not bring both popular characters and lesser known characters out? This is a best of both worlds approach.

Quote:
Originally Posted by IMJ View Post
Inversely, some of these could be fun. I grew up with Swamp Thing on film and it was neat. The Authority is a bizarre pick, but that could be DC's next sophisticated "Watchmen". But for "Universe Building"?
I'm a huge fan of Moore's Swamp Thing and an adaption of that story, done better than the decent television series could really be something special in the world of horror and DC.

Andrew's automatic assertion that it will flop is funny. It's basically an assumption that a Swamp Thing movie can't make money, period. With the right approach, budget, creative team, Swamp Thing, like most things, could be a smash. Let's wait a little bit before deciding what is going to flop, based on a name.

The Authority is a bizarre, yet awesome choice. It's the type of stuff audiences are proving they crave by watching Joker and The Boys in such huge numbers. People like edgy comic book adaptions. Marvel won't do it (Deadpool pending), so DC will. Ironically, Snyder would be an appropriate choice, based on the comics.

Quote:
Originally Posted by IMJ View Post
Honestly they should have completed Snyder's vision and then relaunched with mostly stand-alone films and an occasional crossover film if things went well. We are already seeing with Marvel that long-form continuity can be entertaining but also stifling on a long-enough timeline. This is where you say "it's films not comics" when it comes to the source-material instead of saying that when there is a nonsense deviation on film.
They should have let Snyder finish Justice League part 1 and just axed 2, yeah. We are still getting stand-alone films, thankfully. Batman part 2, Joker, the Coates Superman (if it ever happens), etc.

Last edited by AquaParade; 01-31-2023 at 03:07 PM.
AquaParade is offline   Reply With Quote