View Single Post
Old 05-26-2023, 05:53 PM   #3
DrSpengler
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 4,842
Quote:
Originally Posted by DrSpengler View Post
Aww yeah, this guy right here.

It was an underdeveloped plot point for the original Mirage Shredder, admittedly, but he had a sympathetic or empathetic angle to his origin story. Beyond just wanting to avenge his brother, the text even explicitly states that he was misinformed and manipulated by the Foot Clan hierarchy, making him a "victim" in his own right.

There's a lot of material in that original Mirage Shredder back story that could be used to flesh out the character. While I appreciate that Mirage didn't want to overuse the Shredder and employed him sparingly, at times it felt like a missed opportunity to mine some genuinely fascinating characterization from him.

I think it was... Tristan Jones (?) who said he even pitched a Shredder prequel story to Tales and got it shot down (might have been Ross May; my memory is foggy). Mirage editorial seemed pretty strict in their decree to leave the Shredder alone (save the Shark-Shredder, but that was explained in excruciating detail as not being the "real" Shredder). I get why they wanted to stick to that angle, but there were so many stories that could have been told that couldn't not be explored in other continuities (since, as noted, all other continuities have eliminated Nagi from the formula).
Rereading my original response from 2014 (sweet lord), I stand by it.

THAT SAID, I think the adaptations that have strayed the most from Mirage have found interesting avenues to fill that motivational void once Nagi is eliminated from Shredder's origin.

4Kids had Ch'rell, who was so far removed from any incarnation of the Shredder, with his own crazy origin and motivations, that there really was no room for a sad brother story for him. He had his own nutty stuff going on and I loved all of it for what it was. Wholly unique.

2012 Nickelodeon Shredder, I think in terms of intent (and not always execution), had something going there. Saki and Yoshi fighting over Tang Shen was there, but with the added bonus of Karai having been born to Tang and Yoshi, but abducted by Saki. He raises her as his own daughter as the ultimate F U to Yoshi, but in that span of time comes to genuinely love her as his own, as well as for her being the last piece of Tang Shen left (whom he genuinely cared for).

All the amazing pieces were there, they just didn't always get explored as well as they could. The abuse Shredder often put Karai through to keep her by his side eliminated most any sympathetic qualities to his plight. Still, there was something really unique there which filled the emotional and personal role that an Oroku Nagi would have left behind.

So I don't think removing Nagi for the sake of streamlining origins is entirely bad, I just think his personal weight has to be replaced with something. Anything.
DrSpengler is offline   Reply With Quote