Originally Posted by Powder
I have a lot to say, I don't know that anyone will care to read it all, but I'll have to divide it into 2 posts. & there's so much I'm not even commenting on, I can only imagine how many posts it would take to do a total breakdown.
This movie was pretty unconventional as far as TMNT goes. I'd say it was very on-brand, in that it had all the typical turtle fare, familiar faces, pizza, etc, but a lot of controversial changes were made to the lore & character dynamics, & it's humor is strikingly gen z specific, for the most part. It did many things that longtime traditional fans would likely consider wrong, blasphemous, or even outright disrespectful. Despite that, I really, really liked it. In fact, I think I "get it" a lot more than the majority of fans, though I'm sure my stance will be dismissed as a coping mechanism, brand loyalty, or something akin to that.
I feel that it was marketed pretty honestly, as an experimental parody of sorts that is comedy forward, & primarily targeting teens of today. There's a little something for everyone, but I'd say it services 13-25 year-olds the most, from how the coming of age angle was handled, to the slang & pop culture references. Fortunately for me, this was not an issue. I spend a lot of time on Tiktok, I watch anime, my partner & friends are a few years younger than me, I'm a part of the art/convention scene, so at best I'm well versed in, & at worst peripherally aware of, what's current/funny re: the post-internet zeitgeist. That's not to say it's all up my alley, mind you, but I think that the jokes, phrases, & concepts played with here were implemented to hilarious effect. These turtles & their peers really feel like teenagers, more than ever before, for better or worse. Today's teenagers, especially. These turtles throw out a LOT of zoomer lingo/references, but the turtles we knew did the same with that of their own eras, we just found that relatable as we grew up with them. Now we're old, but they're not. I can see where this would be obnoxious or alienating for millennial & gen x fans, but I got a real kick out of it. I don't think that the creators are by any means trying to sell you on the idea that these trends, behaviors, or times are the best, or even necessarily worth embracing, but rather just commenting on & presenting them as they are. Our boys belong to a corporation now, like it or not, they have to move with the times to keep the money flowing in. No high schooler in 2023 connects with Spicoli.
There were a few moments where I nearly cringed, but I was able to put things into perspective with relative ease. I went into the movie with an open mind, & made a point to take everything in context. In one scene, Donatello sees "Attack on Titan" (the name of a popular anime) scribbled on a high school locker, & giddily exclaims how although he doesn't know who it belongs to, he wants to be their best friend. The gag carries on a little. At first, I thought "Ugh." & then I remembered being a 12 year old wannabe punk rocker & losing my mind if I saw someone wearing a Ramones shirt. "Look, mom, another punk, that guy likes punk rock! Wow, I bet he's cool!" I used stupid made-up words that didn't stand the test of time ("Rizz" will definitely fizzle out by next year). I related intense moments in my reality to the dumb cartoons I liked. Real teens are not cool, yo. Our media markets things in such a way to make you think they are, that they define hip culture, & have these unique little identities- They don't. They're awkward try-hards who misappropriate what they hear & stumble on their own developing egos. They say & do things for the wrong reasons, seldom looking before they leap. They want to fit in so badly, yet they strive to be individuals, all the while resenting the two concepts altogether. I think the outcast factor was honed-in on perfectly, & the bittersweetness of loving your family but wanting to break free from them hit hard here. The creative team repeatedly stated their emphasis on making these turtles feel more like teens than ever before, & whether or not you like that element of the film, they succeeded in doing so. I found it endearing. I am also giving the benefit of the doubt that they'll age-up over time, as this was very obviously an origin story of sorts, given we saw them have their very first battle, personal encounter with a human, etc.
As far as the reactionary stuff is concerned, it should come as no surprise those talking points are overblown, & made largely by those who are just outright looking for axes to grind. Although careful consideration for diversity is apparent, nothing is ham-fisted or shoved in your face. Concerning the lady mutants, I'd prefer they just make new characters as opposed to restructuring old ones to meet a gender representation quota. But at the end of the day, it didn't really effect anything for the worse. It was a little jarring to hear women's voices coming out of the likes of Leatherhead & Wingnut, but it's not as though their designs were altered to reflect their genders. They still look gnarly & serve their purpose, no added hips & bust, no girly colloquialisms, the same 'ole bat & gator. Actually, Scumbug being female now is great, to me. There is absolutely nothing feminine about a disgustingly bloated cockroach that vomits all over the place. Scumbug has long been a favorite of mine, so seeing this character get their time in the spotlight was wildly unexpected, & super funny.
Would I have ever, ever, ever made Scumbug the romantic partner of Master Splinter? Not in a million years. If you told me that I was going to see that become a thing, I'd never believe it. If you told me I was not only going to see it, but enjoy seeing it, I'd slap you. However, that's what happened. Why? I guess I just took it in context. The set-ups leading up to that were funny & well laid out. Gross-out humor is a running theme in this film, as it is in the old toyline & CGI show from 2012. Seth Rogen, famed stoner & envelope-pusher, took that notion & ran with it. I laughed. Sue me. It's a toy commercial, don't expect Shakespeare.
April being black is of no consequence to me, her race has never been essential to her character. I was surprised just how likeable this version of her was, compared to Rise & Platinum Dunes' efforts, who I found over-the-top, & flat, respectively. She wasn't in on the combat, she didn't steal the turtles' thunder, nor was she a caricature of her race. She was simply a friend, connection to the outside world, source of information, & background player, all the things I want an April O'neil to be.
|