Quote:
Originally Posted by Purse Grabbin Puke
You contradict yourself. They steal because maybe they don't like algae and worms, but you also said they steal to survive. This isn't true. They steal because the writers created Splinter to be a piece of ****. Heroes would suck down the food they don't like instead of stealing.
|
I meant them both differently (2012 & MM). We don’t know 2012 version steals but we know they eat but don’t enjoy algae and worms. The other versions don’t eat algae and worms. MM steal for survival. No contradiction.
Quote:
|
And now you've given them the authority to decide who "looks" like they need the things they're stealing. Stealing IS ILLEGAL. If they judged stealing based on who "needs" it more then we'd have hordes of people stealing on a daily basis.
|
You know stealing is illegal, but do they know it is illegal? Like I said they might not have firm grasp of what is morally right and wrong due to being raised by a literal rat who steals for survival. They’re just copying him. Who can tell them what they’re doing is wrong? No one.
Quote:
|
And having them eat algae and worms would fit right into the gross out humor they were going for. It's just pure laziness from the writers to go the route they went with this. Someone else mentioned they could have shown them taking money off of the criminals they beat up. That one simple act is infinitely better than them stealing from upstanding citizens.
|
Algae and worms are for 2012 version only so what’s that got to do with MM?
Quote:
|
They are criminals in the sense they're vigilantes. It's different because being a vigilante is taking the law into your own hands, not stealing from the innocent.
|
Vigilante is still illegal and punishable by law. Ironic that for this crime you’re willing to turn a blind eye but for stealing you went insane? Who’s to say the people they beaten is actually guilty or innocent, they’re not the law to do so in the first place.
Things are not black and white, there’s a lot of grey areas.
Quote:
|
You keep excusing their behavior because of the "rat upbringing". That is the problem. Splinter is written horribly, and at least they do a good job of showing that consistency. Splinter sucks therefore the Turtles are idiot, assholes who also suck. Splinter is the spark that starts the dumpster fire. The bros are supposed to be good guys from the beginning. They shouldn't have to "learn" that fighting crime for fame isn't "right". They should know that already, because Splinter should have taught them. Now can some of the bros want more in life? Want to interact with humans? Sure, they always have this internal struggle. But to be outright criminals and have zero awareness because their father/sensei is a complete moron is not what I want to see in a TMNT movie or show.
|
You should blame yourself then for expecting things to always be the usual cliche and perfect. This is the story they wanted to tell and all these supposed flaws are actually giving them room for character growth and improvements.
The boys didn’t know fighting crime for fame is wrong? That’s what their journey is about, learning to be true heroes and being their authentic selves instead of chasing fame.
There’s a dichotomy of who they wanted to be and who they actually are. They’re not perfect. That’s the beauty of it; it made them endearing and it works. People love them, that’s why this movie is resonating well with the audience and critics alike.