Quote:
Originally Posted by Purse Grabbin Puke
Secondary characters changing race is only being done for political reasons. And people get upset when things are changed for political brownie points. I don't have a problem with April being black, and I really enjoy the actress who plays April, she's fantastic in The Bear. I think in a live action movie if she was cast, I would have been very happy with it. ... April is done very well. My only problem with April is she looks SO unnecessarily odd, with a really odd shape, and they really drive it home how "BEAUTIFUL" she is, and it's just another case of this movie being disingenuous.
|
So the above is just riddled with contradictions, but I guess I'm glad you don't have a problem with April? As far as her odd shape goes... that's kinda a thing with cartoon humans. How many Looney Tunes characters have unrealistic shapes? How many Pixar characters? Etc, etc. But also: I know plenty of actual humans with shapes closer to nu-April's than, say, OT April's. I'd absolutely describe some of them as "beautiful," and even the ones I wouldn't describe accordingly have spouses/partners/etc who would. But also -- and maybe I'm old; I vaguely recall railing about 2012 April (though not to this extent) -- complaining about oddly shaped characters in a movie with mutated animals running around strikes me as kinda wtf. But I also get that focus given that so many people here *haven't even seen the flipping movie* and as such are reduced to commenting on character designs rather than more substantive aspects of the movie.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Purse Grabbin Puke
When I was a kid I knew people didn't all look the same, but I didn't know about racism, or differences in culture. When I watched a movie, or a cartoon, I liked who I liked, and their skin color was the absolute last thing I would EVER think about. I'm not sure how I got them, but I got Macho Man and a Junk Yard Dog thumb wrestlers. My favorite one was Junk Yard Dog. My favorite Yankees player was Roberto Kelly. My favorite Ghostbuster was Winston. I'm white. I liked who I liked. If you base things on race, and "representation" you're espousing some kind of racism. And the sad truth is, people of color ARE under represented in Hollywood. But instead of replacing white characters with another race, how about we create new stories for people of color. Replacement is always going to cause fighting.
|
Here's the thing -- *any* sort of representation is going to cause fighting. *Anything* people can call "woke" is going to cause fighting. There are plenty of "new" stories being told involving diverse casts, and they get condemned as woke liberal garbage. But also -- every incarnation of TMNT is a new story. They may take cues and inspiration from characterization and arcs and so on from previous iterations, but they're new. (I feel like the concept of the multiverse *should* make people more receptive to this, but eh.) And as far as your childhood experience goes... good for you, I guess? I feel like I thought that was how my childhood experience went too, and yet I can also vividly recall being told I couldn't be Egon or Batman or Joker because of the color of my skin. (If you've seen Stranger things, that scene where Lucas showed up dressed as Peter and the exchange that followed was *perfect*.) In fact, one of the reasons I liked TMNT and other properties with anthro protagonists is that I *could* be any of the heroes without my peers giving me **** because I didn't look like them. So if Mutant Mayhem (or Rise) means little black girls don't have their white so-called friends crapping on them for cosplaying as April O'Neil, I'm fine with that.
[QUOTE=Andrew NDB;1971662]Not remotely the same thing. White Baxter Stockman was only created because TPTB weren't comfortable portraying a black man as a villain. Which, again, is a bit sinister if we step back and look at a show aimed at kids who are still forming thoughts and ideas in their heads and only giving them cartoons where the bad guys are always only allowed to be white. That sends a pretty not so great message, I think./QUOTE]
Oh, come now -- they're obviously *remotely* the same thing. I question your description of what actually happened -- apparently this came up years ago in another Tdrome thread; there are conflicting testimonies:
https://forums.thetechnodrome.com/sh...ad.php?t=39188 -- but if that *was* in the mix then it's even more similar than you realize. Ostensibly April was made black in order to give black girls positive representation. According to this narrative, Baxter was made white in order to avoid giving black boys/men negative representation. These are not dissimilar motives. And honestly, especially given some of the treatment I've received throughout my life, I have a problem with neither of those objectives. I've yet to hear any arguments that I found compelling even attempt to grapple with the core of those concerns. Speculative fears that kids will learn that bad guys are only/always white -- in a society where so goddamned much media is inundating them with messaging that is very much *not* that -- ain't it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
Oh, I've taken plenty of time looking into the ideology. Way too much, I think, and certainly more than it deserves. I can definitely understand the appeal to a certain type of person and, of course, it feels really good to fight on behalf of some kind of cause.
|
Listening to descriptions from PragerU and the likes of Matt Walsh doesn't count, but agree to disagree -- your rhetoric and phrasing don't at all align with what someone who *actually* understood "the ideology" would say. But that's a longer exchange, and I don't think this is the place for it. Suffice it to say that just as y'all would vouch for me here -- thanks for that -- I've put a *lot* of work and *engagement* into understanding those who disagree with me politically (though at the end of the day I think these aren't or shouldn't be "political" disputes). I think many of them are idiots. (My friend in the video is not an idiot.) But just as I think it's ignorant AF to go to these lengths to criticize a movie y'all haven't even seen, I think it's ignorant AF to broadly criticize people you haven't made an attempt to understand by engaging with them directly *and in good faith*. And if you're giggling about silly-ass fantasies of trolling said people, I'm almost certain that's not where you're coming from.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/make-am...conversations/
Okay. It's pretty clear that sadly any comments of value are going to be drowned out by the chorus of folks who can't be assed to learn what they're talking about, so I'm done commenting here. See y'all intermittently on the toy threads until the next movie. Sigh.