Quote:
Originally Posted by Mayhem
The right of the people, plural, collective all the population. If the Government was to say no one could have guns, that’s a pretty go against the wording statement. And there’s no definition about what arms. Most people generally don’t need semi automatic rifles. Those two things SHOULD be the role of the law to maintain safety, security, and reduce gun related crime.
|
Yes, the right of the people (individual citizens within the population) to bear arms is well enshrined in our case law. It does not have to say specifically what arms because they knew technology advances. We dont codify exactly where you can speak in the 1st amendment but that does not stop free speech online for instance. However they dont need to codify it because arms are weapons. They acknowledged that this right is necessary to help form Militias which are citizen soldiers. It doesn't matter if *you* think they need semi-automatic rifles (that fire one shot with one pull of the trigger like any pistol does) they are a necessity for a free society. In a perfect world it would be up to the law, but the law (like police) cant be everywhere at all times to protect you and you *should* take responsibility to keep yourself safe.
If it makes you feel better about it, I am sure the founding fathers knew that the machine gun had been invented something like 1718 so its pretty safe to think they would understand one day we would have better weapons that could shoot faster.
Quote:
|
I’ve never advocated for guns to be banned in the US, just the checks and balances to be a lot more stringent than they are. But you’re essentially saying that mentally ill people should be allowed unlimited access to firearms because the Second Amendment trumps any government law. Gotcha. Answer me, which country has on average two mass killings per day? Because it isn’t here. And of the three major shooting incidents I can think of that prompted changes in the gun ownership laws here, two were carried out by determined mentally ill people.
|
I am agreeing with you slightly, some people probably shouldn't have guns.
However, you are advocating for a guilty until proven innocent approach. I am advocating that we don't remove rights from people who have not committed crimes. That's not even getting into the gun stores that refuse to sell to people who are sketchy (which is the majority of them).
I don't care about mass shootings. Murder is illegal. If you commit a crime with a gun then you cant own a gun. Its also not likely that people who intend to commit murder
wont find another way.
Quote:
|
I won’t even go into the news that I saw this morning that a store in Texas (where else?!) has installed the first ammunition vending machine like you’re ordering from McDonalds. Waiting for that to get hacked and all the ammo dumped by someone unscrupulous.
|
I think this is both good and bad. On the good side, citizens should have the freedom to buy their ammo whenever a shopkeeper will sell it to them. Smells like freedom, hoo-rah. On the bad side, those
purchase records and IDs can be ordered by the court when they are trying to throw darts at a board when trying to pin something on a gun owning citizen who commits thought crime.
Quote:
|
I’m intrigued by the “hurt people’s feelings in the UK” comment if you care to provide a link? Online abuse, racism and the such is being taken more seriously, simply because if you said it to that persons face, you’d get decked. So the cowards hide behind a screen.
|
Off hand I can think of two...
Count Dankula for pranking his wife,
here is a big list of speech that I disagree with people are getting arrested for,
here is someone being arrested for retweeting something.
The only reason I am not surprised that
JK Rowling hasn't been arrested is because she has enough money to fight the Scottish courts and win.