View Single Post
Old 08-25-2025, 06:55 PM   #4
d_osborn
Mad Scientist
 
d_osborn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 1,426
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
Mirage TMNT -- golden.
TMNT 1990 -- great, but also overrated in some pretty obvious ways.
…
Everything else? Yeah, pretty much Bantha poodoo. Or at least not really worth bothering with if you're above the age of about 5. Or you're just some kind of McTMNT™ completist nut, out there to support The Franchise as if TMNT is to be some kind of church or religion. I've met plenty of those types.
We’re pretty close! Personally for me, add Secret of the Ooze to “not definitive TMNT to me but will always have a huge spot in my heart.“ The Fred Wolf show is there, as well, although I wouldn’t dare revisit it. Any cartoon of that era, really. The memories are great, though.

I also love digging through the franchise’s cinema history and collecting production artifacts. Diving deep into the projects I read about in magazines in junior high that had me curious: TMNT 4, Burton’s Superman Lives, Ghostbusters: Hellbent.

My interest shouldn’t be taken as defense of their quality or whether I think they would have been good movies.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
That's pretty funny. I mean, you're not wrong. But "capable hands" could save just about anything. On paper, though, TMNT 4 was pure unadulterated crap.
On paper, I’d say it reads quality-wise about like the original scripts for 2 and 3. So, yeah, I agree.

The script circulating is the first draft and things were pared down quite a bit in later drafts. I don’t think the money was there at that point to have made a quality film, but it’s an interesting part of the franchise history.

I can’t remember where I read this, I want to say a Kevin Munroe (2007 movie director) interview. He mentioned something about Laird being very particular about story ideas for being new and didn’t want rehashes of prior TMNT stories. I wonder if this is why TMNT 4 was heading in that weird direction and not back to the franchise roots.

IMO, the speed bump that kept TMNT 4 from going forward was the “advanced mutations” idea. The idea of a Ronin Turtle from an alternate dimension with a futuristic, high-tech, gritty NYC visits our TMNT was a solid enough idea on it’s own. Less FX, less budget than the needless Next Mutations.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
Is that true? Wow, if so.
Maybe they were even engaged? I can’t remember, I’m pretty sure it was on the Turtle Tracks Podcast. Turco OR Strain in a tattered black catsuit would’ve been a welcome addition to the franchise, imho.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew NDB View Post
Alt Universe April as the evil empress lady would check out from what I've heard, I guess.
She was a minion of Spyder and had turned against her turtles, leading to the death of their Splinter and the three other turtles.

Last edited by d_osborn; 08-25-2025 at 07:02 PM.
d_osborn is offline   Reply With Quote