View Single Post
Old 11-29-2025, 08:50 AM   #34
ToTheNines
Col. Stinkmeaner
 
ToTheNines's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 19,412
Quote:
Originally Posted by neatoman View Post
I think the argument that "Everyone but Mike is dead and he dies too" for why nobody would like it is rather weak. See, I can think of at least one well liked movie that made over 600 million where the "All but one of the heroes are already dead and he dies too by the end" premise is very much the case. You might have heard of it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToTheNines View Post
Yeah but that was the END (and of dubious/confusing canonical status).

Of course Marvel is still bleeding Jackman’s Wolverine dry since they got the rights, but Mangold was putting a cap on everything, not starting something.

EDIT: another caveat is that Wolverine works as a solo character. The TMNT kinda don’t.

Also, Logan was at least somewhat tied to the (confusing clusterf*ck) of previous X-Men movies, so there was a sense of consequence to what happened. Last Ronin most likely would have been a new universe. Which is cheap.

But the alternative is making it a long sequel to the 90’s movies and bring back Rist and Hoag for the main roles. But no one wants to see those versions of the other 3 brothers, Splinter and Casey cut down in their prime. It’s a lose/lose.
Expanding on this because I love to ramble.

Looked it up and Logan is officially an alternate universe known as Earth 17315. Kinda chicken sh*t, but doesn’t make it a bad movie. I would also argue that the comics that Logan is loosely based on are way better than TLR.

Logan was also a big budget movie with a real director who was allowed to play around with the genre a little bit. You know Paramount was absolutely not going to do anything like that for an experimental TMNT movie.

Quote:
Originally Posted by TheLabRat View Post
I think the Ronin's identity should remain a mystery so that he can embody the characteristics of the four turtle brothers in various ways. He should mostly fight alone, though he may occasionally appear to help April and her allies, but he will quickly retreat into the shadows. Even at the end, April didn't know the Ronin's true identity.
I disagree. As much sh*t as I give Last Ronin, I think the identity reveal with the 3 ghost brothers at the end of #1 was very effective. Unfortunately it didn’t hold my interest much longer after that.

But I do think they’d have to change the identity to keep things interesting. In my head, Raph makes the most sense since he was the main character of 1990. It could also work better thematically, having Raph’s hotheaded mistakes be the reason everyone got killed and him having to live with the guilt.
ToTheNines is offline   Reply With Quote