View Single Post
Old 03-04-2026, 04:32 PM   #12
neatoman
Overlord
 
neatoman's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: Stockholm
Posts: 11,097
Quote:
Originally Posted by ToTheNines View Post
That’s not what he’s saying at all. He’s saying that if you were following that book as it came out, the mini and first 4 issues of the ongoing are obviously FW adaptations (except for little things like Vernon Prinole, or Irma’s drastically different appearance like Coola said), then #5 was obviously a new story but doesn’t necessarily contradict anything, so maybe it’s still the same continuity.

But with #6, the show staff and comic staff were just obviously not in any form of contact. It’s hard to know the actual timeline of conception, pre-production, completion and release of #6 vs. Leatherhead’s debut, but they had clearly already completely diverged and neither team cared what the other was doing.
I don't get why you think I misunderstood that. Of course I understand that if you were to read the Leatherhead debut issue when it came out, the contradiction with the show wouldn't technically happen until a few weeks later when his debut episode aired. All I did was just point out that it doesn't really matter if the contradiction happened on purpose or not.

The rest of the post is building on the question on when it was "decided" it should be its own thing, rather than just possibly being contradictory by accident/indifference, then it would at the latest be villain exile because that's a huge deliberate turn in the story that the show was never going to do that. This is however a different premise from whether or not the early stories could have fit into the show's continuity, I'm not claiming either creative team knew or cared what the other did. It's that if the intention was to stick to continuity with the show at the beginning, which I don't believe was the case just to be clear, then the clearest deliberate deviation from that would be the exile. It's a different discussion building on the same post. Sorry if that was a bit confusing.

Pointing out that FW Leatherhead's backstory is more similar to the Mirage origin (though only vaguely resembling it in the first place) than Archie's, which is something completely different from either origin, at the start of the post probably didn't help with clarity either. I'll admit it doesn't have much relevance, I was just kind of trying to express that Archie Leatherhead's origin is so unique and different from what anyone would expect even at the time, that I can't exactly blame anyone for this particular contradiction. Had Archie Leatherhead simply been a mutated alligator, like he was in Mirage and ultimately in FW, then one could have conceivably still acted as if there was continuity for longer.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by JTH View Post
Turtles is basically the red-headed stepchild of Nick.
Hahahaha!
neatoman is offline   Reply With Quote