Well, I'm 15, and I act much like Leonardo, who already acts older than the others.

Yes, there is the dark side to the turtles that makes them seem older. I don't go fighting thugs or anything, but I do have a martial art background that goes back a long time ago.
It depends on how you look at it, the turtles have Master Splinter as a guide, so he's been leading them on the right track ever since they were capable of learning. So, it would make sense to say that they are mature for their age... for the most part. Maybe they are being portrayed a little older than they should, but I'm 15 and I usually act much like them.