Raphael. It's been that way since I've been something like three years old.
When I was younger, I thought the sarcastic Raph was the epitome of cool. I was very sarcastic and stubborn until I was about 10, which was also about the time when TMNT kinda disappeared.
Now that it's back and the characters are closer to the originals, I find that I'm STILL just like Raphael - only I've evolved as well. I'm more of a hot-head (although I solve my problems with emotional outburts that include yelling, screaming, and crying instead of with violence), and much more intense than I was before.
Of course, I see more of the other Turtles in me now, too. (Is this getting corny or what?!) I'm attempting to find a center and purpose for myself like Leo, I've embraced the geeky side in my like Don, and I'm a total goof-off sometimes, like Mikey.
But, yeah. I've always best related to Raph. Before, it was the attitude, and now, it's something about the intensity and the whole "journey to find your inner, calmer self while blowing up a few million times along the way" thing.
EDIT: Grammar issue.