Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ninja Tiptup
I love DBZ but I hate GT. So I'd rather have TMNT and Samurai Jack. But given the fanbase of TMNT... If it wont do well with 6-11 kids on CN then they should air it later for the older viewers who love the show.
CN tried hard to make TMNT work though. I do believe airing it 7 days a week wasn't the best of ideas... but that never seemed to kill Dragonball Z's ratings nor Teen Titans...
|
TMNT is very different from DBZ and Teen Titans, which was kind of the point of my post. While DBZ is a bit more similar to the Turtles in structure, the storylines are simpler and the pace is much, much slower, so kids can get away with missing episodes and still enjoy the brawny super-guys beating the crap out of each other. (This isn't to say that DBZ doesn't have a significant teen and twenty-something audience, it does... it is just that they didn't make up the majority of the audience watching the censored version on Toonami).
Teen Titans is a completely different type of show from TMNT entirely. It is like comparing an updated version of the old TMNT cartoon to the new one (the TT are even addicted to Pizza). Most of the episodes are self-contained, it is primarily humor based with some action, and it doesn't take itself nearly as seriously as TMNT.
And TMNT DID work on Miguzi, despite the fact I was unsure about pushing it to a gender-neutral Y7 crowd. It wasn't yanked off after two weeks like Energon was, it lasted on Miguzi for a long time. A significant portion of that time, if I am not mistaken, it pulled in the second-highest ratings of the block.
I would bet my right arm that the decline started because most of the sampled viewers simply couldn't follow what was going on anymore, as in the second and third seasons, one had to really follow from arc to arc to have a clue as to what was going on.
I think TT is one of the better animated shows on TV right now, but I think it is unfortunate that unless a show is developed nearly exclusively for a Y7 audience, or is brazenly controversial and intended for an "adult audience" (just look at most of adult swim, the shows are practicaly screaming "hide the kids, we are going to make STD jokes and shoot people in the heart, because THIS IS FOR ADULTS DAMMIT!) it has a tough time finding its place on Cable TV.
Another example is Gargoyles. Just think of what it went through with Disney, going up against Power Rangers. Do you think Gargoyles would have done well on Miguzi? I love Gargoyles, but Gargoyles is not Yu-Gi-Oh or Pokemon. Yet, Disney wanted it to be.
That is what I meant by "unless it can be packaged in like everything else, to hell with it" as the mindset at CN. TMNT is a show a whole family can enjoy; it is unique and has a relatively sophisticated plotline running across its seasons, but CN doesn't really care. It is not that they are evil or don't care about good animation. They just don't think they can pull in large numbers of viewers with anything that doesn't fit the two molds I described, so if a show doesn't fit those archetypes, it will have a tough time getting any attention from cable networks.
What is getting TMNT past the 100 episode mark is that the show still has the coolest concept going: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles! Kids still eat that up, and now we have a great show to go with it. But what rakes in the money is not the great writing, it is the cool-looking Toys, DVDs, school supplies, etec., that kids can't get enough of, and that kids with beards are rediscovering. Just look at your local Wal-Mart. How much Teen Titans stuff is there, and how much TMNT stuff is there? At every outlet I have been to, there is no contest.
I just think it is unfortunate that CN and other networks can't see the potential of cartoons created for an audience of all ages, that aren't predominantly comedies and that take themselves seriously.
That being said, TMNT had a very strong run on Miguzi considering that it was probably out-of-place from day one.