I think Bishop definitely has some potential. The first time I saw him, I was in complete awe, having never seen a TMNT villain like him before. As for Shredder and Bishop being equals...I'd have to say nuh-uh. While I think they can hold their own in a fight against each other, I think the Shredder's warrior spirit made him more formidable, and he inspired more loyalty. That's got to count for something. Plus he was a worldly brain alien.
But maybe I need to see more of Bishop...