Thread: TMNT fighting
View Single Post
Old 05-10-2005, 01:21 AM   #7
Sage Ninja
Band of the Hawk
 
Sage Ninja's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: USA
Posts: 3,927
ok people this is turning into a Vs. thread. I think we should get rid of "better than" because this is not about what turtle fights the best its about how they fight and how well they can hold their own in battle. And lets be honest here, all the turtles can hold their own pretty well in fights; either by them selves or together. If they couldn't neighther of them would have survived the first episode

Quote:
Originally Posted by darthsith19
Ever notice that with Hun he got more and more confident and involved? He knew how Hun fought so he knew just how to approach.
Which Hun battle?

Each one. The first encounter he was the usual reluctant fighter, but as he got more used to battling Hun, he became more confident in fighting him out of past experience.
That is not exactly true, sure Mikey seems to be the most er, timid when it comes to fighting new oppents but he not like that all the time. Mikey is actually pretty impulsive and fights even though he doesn't know much about what that oppent can do. In Aprils Aritface he took on the Queen wasp on his own for a bit with out squealing like a girl and plenty of other oppents in several other instances with out knowing what to expect from them.

Quote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by darthsith19
The only reason how he beat Raphael in the tournament was by living with him his whole life. He used Raph's temper against him. That's not powerful brains on his part, just common sense.
So you seriiusly believe that if he hadn't been living with Raph his whole life he would have lost? Got any proof? Mikey has done better in all the battles they've had

No, I believe that if he hadn't known about Raphael's anger, he would have a harder time fighting him. I never said whether he would have won or not. The only reason why he won, and was so cocky while doing it, was because of his knowledge on his brother. Otherwise, it would have been a longer fight, and harder to determine the winner.
Common sence is very essenticial in a fight and not to be down played. And you do have to be smart at least just a little bit to have common sence.

And I actually have to disagree with that just a little bit. Michaelangelo is capable of putting up a very good fight when it suits him and when he wants to. However Mikey's main objective uasually is to have fun allot of times and be a super hero. However because i think that Mike is a glory hound he used an advantage to get the fight over quickly so he could bask in it the glory of it. But if it suited him to have a longer fight and he would find some enjoyment in it, he would have. And have done a pretty good job as well.

Quote:
Originally Posted by darthsith19
All the good quaities in Mikey that you're pushing on the others here only leads to these two things: fear and survival. Fear can drive you to fight harder in order to survive. Also, when a situation calls for a need to survive, that as well can raise your determination and urge to go on.
Okay, if you say so, but Mikey still fights better. If it's out of fear then so what? he still fights better. And he isn't afraid anymore. he was only afraid in the first season.


What? So you're saying that fear as a catalyst is better than focus, drive, discipline, determination, and desire when it comes to fighting? Leonardo would wave you off at that comment. Mikey fights more out of fear and the need to survive than actual focus and skill. He's still afraid of things, if you'd notice the way he backs off with his hands in front of him and keeps saying, "Whoa."
Yeah I would have to agree that Mikey isn't the coward that he was made out to be in the first season. I believe that he has improved and become less skittish than he was before. Michaelangelo doesn't just have fear driving him in battle he actually ,like all the other turtles has the desire to suceed and beat the bad guy of the day. And to say that Mikey fights more out of fear than skill is not true. Mikey does display skill when he fights and has the focus when he wants to.

Quote:
Originally Posted by darthsith19
And Mikey can't be better than Splinter....none of the boyshave surpassed their master.
Yes, but he still managed to come up with a plan before Splinter could. It was thanks to Mikey that he and Splinter survived.


Again, because of survival. Also, I'm pretty sure that his master by his side inspired him to use his brain more than usual.
Give Mikey a little more credit in the brain and skill area. I think Michaelangelo displayed quite a bit of resourcefulness and independence in this episode, had Splinter not been there I have no doubt in my mind that Michaelangelo would have figured out how to beat them, Mikey is actually rather observant. Splinter even said in this very episode that michaelangelo had the skill and was physically capable of being a good ninja but he just wasn't putting his mind into it. Which he finnally did in this episode.

And also your making the surviaval thing out to be nothing. Some times the best way to learn is to be put in a life or death situation. When your thrown into a dangeruos situation you kind of have to learn on the spot how to cope and adapt to it. Sometimes that can be the best learning, and if you survive it like Mikey does than you made are wiser and stronger as a result. Kind of like being out in the wild, you eighther learn on the go or you don't and you don't survive.

Quote:
Quote:
Originally Posted by darthsith19
speaking of Rogue....Mikey does get his shell shellacked by the Splinter-mech...while Raph and Leo plot to take him out with Zog....Mikey is simply blocking the mechs blows...a testiment to his speed...not his skill
So his speed doesn't contribute to his skill? If 2 people are identical but one is faster then they have the same skills? I think not.

Having speed doesn't necessarily mean you have skill. I don't know how to fight using ninjitsu, but even I can quickly block punches for a long period of time.
Alright I'm not going to pretend that i am an expert in ninjitsu or anything, but I have taken some martical arts and being quick is indeed a crucial skill. And the fact that Mikey is very agile and quick means he had to have allot practice in being able to anticapate some ones moves to avoid them on the spot. You would think that this would be easy, some one is about to hit you than move, actually not really. And being fast is essebtical to being a ninja.
Sage Ninja is offline   Reply With Quote