Alright, then....
Donnie: Probably build himself a lab (go figure) and try to find a cure for cancer or something.
Leo: Uhm... *thinks about it* This is kind of hard, consiedering Leo has devoted alot of his life towards ninjitsu... Probably try to make sure that his brothers won't get into trouble... And he'd probably be the one to take care of Splinter, as well.
I can see Leo living in Japan.
Raph: Another difficult one. I can see him living somewhere in the city, but thats just about it.

My favorite turtle and I can't even think about what he'd be like if he never learned to fight... Ill try to think about it and if I can come up with anything I'll edit this post later...
Mikey: Probably write poetry, novels, and draw things... or maybe help out people in need (like Big Brothers Big Sisters, Jimmy Fund, etc.)
Shredder: Well, there are no turtles around to stop him from taking over... unless some other opposing force went against him.