View Single Post
Old 08-23-2005, 09:53 PM   #13
Jaf
Foot Soldier
 
Jaf's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Montréal (Québec)
Posts: 106
mediums and standards...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
You see, the difference here is, those artists are cartoonists. They draw cartoons. Short, comical, not to be taken seriously cartoons.
Vaughn Bodé is a CARTOONIST?!?!?!? And do you seriously pretend that Schulz's Peanuts is not to be taken seriously?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
Jim Lawson, however, is drawing a mature, (supposed to be) action oriented comic book. There's a big difference. If you don't believe me, then answer me this: Could you imagine Jim Davis or Charles M. Schulz penciling an issue of X-Men?
Well, lad, ain't no Mirage artist that would even WANT to draw X-Men!! Laird and Eastman plainly HATE Marvel because of what they did to Jack Kirby! They refused to work for Marvel back in the days the turtles were the «next big thnig»; in fact, they LAUGHED at those big Marvel executives when presented with their new working conditions : «That's all you can offer? Then let's forget it, dudes, it's all the way back to NoHo for us!»

And... wait a sec'... are you suggesting that X-Men and that kind of comics are «mature» and «to be taken seriously» opposed to Peanuts or Garfield?
Granted, the X-Men flick was great pro gay rights propaganda...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
The point is, those artists are working with a different medium, with different standards.
You're right on that : there is cartoons, comics... and comix. Face it man, TMNT is NOT a mainstream comic franchise, because Mirage don't want it to be. When they tried to launch the Next sub-company back in the '90s, Mirage said it was their first take at one fun genre : the supehero comic. Meaning : they never considered anything they published before as «superhero» comics. X-Men can be great (or Batman, Avengers, Sup', name it), but it is undoubtebly a superhero comic. Mirage & TMNT = comix; different medium, different standard. They may be walking the thin line, but just look at the people they publish! It's clear where their hearts lie.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
And quite honestly, I believe that if it weren't for Laird, Lawson would have never made it in the comic book industry using the style he's using now.
And the whole point, the «raison d'être», the goal of Mirage, Tundra, the Xeric or TMNT is to give some highly talented folks with a distinctive and unique style a publishing medium by which they are not bound by the industry's conservative standards.

«The Ninja Turtles comics were an enjoyable experience; there was absolute artistic and editorial freedom, and, flush with its success, the parent company was extremely generous with its money.» Milton Knight speaking. And no, Knight never did X-Men
No hard feelings, Elite5Raph, but this whole anti-Lawson vendetta is seriously starting to get frustrating by the thickness of its argumentation. People should read the stuff they like; I have a hard time understanding why people who don't like Mirage comics in general would continue to read it for some mysterious attachment to the basic concept of some of its characters. The big companies are full of other titles they could enjoy!
Jaf is offline   Reply With Quote