Quote:
|
Originally Posted by verminator_x
i liked this one much better than the prisoner of azkaban.
but it didnt go all the way, as the two first harry potter movies.
.
|
No offense to you, but I don't like how people expect these types of movies to "go all the way" wtih the book. It's literally impossible. Even the Lord of the Rings movies had to cut out some parts from the books.
The reason i think the first two movies were able to "go all the way" was because those two books were short, less than 250 pages or something like that.
Now, I like it if movies contained as much of the book as possible, but I don't expect them to. I think that's the way people should go into movies based off books. I'm satisfied if the movies manages to convey the FEEL of the books, and although I had to admit that Harry potter IV wasn't a perfect adaptation (I didn't even realize how Dumbledore acted until you guys told me about it--I'm deaf remember?) I got the dark tone and the teen angst from the book. Even though the parts that should have had the most darkness and angst, like the graveyard scene, was missing, I felt that the movie as a whole got the atmosphere right.