View Single Post
Old 12-02-2005, 10:52 AM   #129
heretic888
Foot Elite
 
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,344
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
I've noticed that things like this always look more clear when you work it out mathematicly.

We can work out a fighter's statistics through some basic categories...
  • Physical strength and endurance.
  • Agility, speed, and reflexes.
  • Resourceful thinking, scanning, and calculating.
  • Spirit, focus, and drive.
I personally don't agree with the aforementioned list at all, nor is it the approach to combat taken in ninpo.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Setting the scoring system as 1 - 5 (1 being the lowest and 5 being the highest), here's the rating for each TMNT...
Many of these statistics have already been laid out in the Palladium TMNT RPG, which Eastman & Laird worked closely on in the early days of the license and which Dan Berger told me is a more or less agreed upon interpretation of their characters.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Physical strength and endurance

Leo - 4
Don - 3
Raph - 5
Mikey - 3
This is completely wrong.

In terms of Physical Strength (P.S.), their actual scores are:
- Raphael: 20
- Michelangelo: 16
- Leonardo: 15
- Donatello: 13

In terms of Physical Endurance (P.E.)., their actual scores are:
- Raphael: 20
- Leonardo: 18
- Michelangelo: 17
- Donatello: 13

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Agility, speed, and reflexes

Leo - 4
Don - 3
Raph - 3
Mikey - 5
Close, but somewhat off the mark.

In terms of Physical Prowess (P.P.), the actual scores are:
- Michelangelo: 24
- Leonardo: 20
- Raphael: 18
- Donatello: 17

In terms of Speed (Spd.), the actual scores are:
- Raphael: 15
- Michelangelo: 14
- Leonardo: 11
- Donatello: 10


Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Resourceful thinking, scanning, and calculating

Leo - 4
Don - 5
Raph - 3
Mikey - 3
The closest equivalent to this in the RPG is Intelligence Quotient (I.Q.), which doesn't directly have anything to do with combat:
- Donatello: 19
- Leonardo: 16
- Raphael: 12
- Michelangelo: 11

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Spirit, focus, and drive

Leo - 5
Don - 3
Raph - 3
Mikey - 3
Difficult to evaluate this, but the closest things are Mental Endurance (M.E.) and Mental Affinity (M.A.).

Mental Endurance (M.E.):
- Leonardo: 16
- Donatello: 15
- Michelangelo: 14
- Raphael: 13

Mental Affinity (M.A.):
- Michelangelo: 19
- Leonardo: 17
- Donatello: 13
- Raphael: 11

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
Total Fighter rank...

Leo - 17
Don - 14
Raph - 14
Mikey -14
Well, ignoring Physical Beauty (P.B.) here, the total rank of the TMNT's actual Palladium attributes are:
- Raphael: 109
- Leonardo: 113
- Donatello: 99
- Michelangelo: 115

So --- going by Intelligence Quotient, Mental Endurance, Mental Affinity, Physical Strength, Physical Endurance, Physical Prowess, and Speed alone --- Michelangelo just edges out Leonardo, barely.

Of course, some of these attributes don't directly affect combat (such as I.Q.) but I would be willing to accept alternative uses of the relative ability scores outside of the mechanics of the Palladium combat system. Additionally, there are other things to take into consideration in the game (Leonardo, for example, is one experience level higher than Michelangelo which means he has one more attack per melee round and a slightly higher Weapon Proficiency bonus). But, all in all, they're pretty evenly matched.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ryona
I really think that the official site should have a ranking chart like this posted up. It's clear, honest, true, and fair.
There is already an "official ranking chart" like this in the Palladium TMNT RPG. Look it up.

Laterz.
__________________
"Ninpo began as training to become a moral people and to learn to endure in whatever social condition one is in; to know and accept one's fate, and to live for human beings and all other creatures. The person who masters all of these is a Ninja." (Masaaki Hatsumi)
heretic888 is offline   Reply With Quote