He's a good villain, yes... but when they essentially promise us that he won't be returning, I'd like to see them go through with that. It also allows them the story flexibility of bringing in new awesome villains (like Bishop) instead of allowing the show to go in circles, fighting the same fight against the same villain. Keeps it fresher...
...But I do like when they bring Shredder's
influence back to haunt the Turtles; things he's done or caused to happen (like Karai) that screw up their lives... and he doesn't even have to be there. Even when gone, he can still be a pain in the neck for our stalwart heroes.